Advancement Resources
Scouting ranks, merit bades, and the advancement programs
2426 topics in this forum
-
- 101 replies
- 9.2k views
-
- 58 replies
- 5.7k views
-
- 19 replies
- 1.6k views
-
- 24 replies
- 1.9k views
-
- 55 replies
- 4.4k views
-
- 5 replies
- 663 views
-
- 20 replies
- 1.8k views
-
- 15 replies
- 2k views
-
- 72 replies
- 6.4k views
-
- 36 replies
- 3.3k views
-
- 10 replies
- 1.5k views
-
- 10 replies
- 3.7k views
-
- 7 replies
- 1.7k views
-
- 64 replies
- 8.1k views
-
- 11 replies
- 1k views
-
LATEST POSTS
-
That would be entirely logical. The position largely invalidates the perspective. -
When I go to most camporees and summer camp, the vast majority of scouts are white males. If our scouting organization wants to include other demographics, it may need to have recruiting efforts or events targeted to those demographics. It doesn't mean changing the program or, hopefully, removing standard events. Each year at summer camp, the leaders of the one girls Troop that attends has raised concerns about behavior. Over time, I've seen less girls attending. If BSA wants to remain primarily a program for white males, then don't make any changes. If they want to expand to other groups, then between the choice of changing the program or implementing some special events, Id support implementation of these special events. Over time, I would expect these special events would fade, but it takes a long time for acceptance of new members by existing organization members and for the general public to see scouting as a program for more than just suburban and rural white males. When my daughter joined our mountain bike team, she was one of 3 girls on a 55 person team. She was called slow by the boys. She was called a boy by them and her non biking friends. She dealt with a lot of crap my son didn't go through. The mountain bike organizer created some special events for girls and that helps her feel appreciated. Now, we have 7 girls out of 60 or so total. Over time, if there are more girls, she won't feel she as isolated as she once did. I would also agree we need to do better with suburban and rural white males as well, but I don't think think we need a dedicated event for them as every event I attend is 90%+ that demographic. -
By AwakeEnergyScouter · Posted
I certainly don't trust people who make it clear that they don't think I should be where I am to give me advice or support. I am curious about whether that it's girls only scout craft catch-up says something about just how stiff that cultural resistance is in that council. In principle, just make it a scoutcraft basics camporee open to all new units. But why didn't they? The comments that remain make me wonder if the reason is that so many male scouts are opposed to girls that it wouldn't work to help the girls, or that the council had solid reasons to think it would end up there. -
By AwakeEnergyScouter · Posted
I agree that the quality of the program is going to fall on the den leaders to make sure they are choosing to do the engaging fun stuff instead of just what is easy for them, but that has always been the case - that's not a change. I'm not sure what you mean by "wiggle room" in what's required where, but in the case of Bear Habitat (which is rank required) there is only one activity suggested for requirement 7, which is the one I posted above. Unless Scoutbook doesn't have requirement 7 as required, which I can't check right now, it would seem that Bears are still required to make animal sign observations. That verbiage is even the same as before. Or am I missing something here? I was hoping that seeing that it wasn't in fact the case that you can walk the mile on a track without paying any attention would be heartening, but perhaps it wasn't. May all beings be happy regardless. -
On of those "what if" things for me. I was an ASM for a troop at Spangdahlem AB in the sixties, predating I believe the Normandy COR. But it would have been on our radar for sure if was there when it happened. As it turned out, I was moved anyway to a remote sight with no scouting, and only seven of us. Later I took a pass to France, but did not get to Normandy, though wish I had now. I did visit the Luxembourg cemetery, and the one at Cambridge in England. The first one, Luxembourg was a real eye opener for me, as I had yet to see Pearl or Arlington. Cambridge is unique in that it has a huge wall with names engraved on it; all men and a few women that were lost in the Atlantic from sunken ships and downed planes. When I did go to Arlington in 85 with our Jambo troop, I noted a somberness that overcame most of the scouts and leaders, especially those with Veterans as leaders. I watched one Scouter stand just a ways back from the Wall, near the two statue guards and bow his head. His scouts gave him space, and then he walked to the Wall and found a name or maybe more, bowed his head again and finally turned and walked away. The look on the faces of the Scouts was respect and sympathy. I have a photo of myself reflected in the Wall looking at the name of a HS friend, and you can see me with his name in the reflection. A very cool picture. That is why we try to always participate in local Veteran related activities, especially Memorial Day and Veterans' Day.
-
-
Who's Online (See full list)