Jump to content

Issues & Politics

In answer to many requests, we established a separate forum for these topics. Those not interested can skip this forum instead of spending time reading unwanted messages to identify content.

2654 topics in this forum

    • 15 replies
    • 1021 views
    • 1 reply
    • 340 views
    • 42 replies
    • 1795 views
    • 20 replies
    • 1211 views
    • 90 replies
    • 5073 views
  1. Job opening at National

    • 36 replies
    • 1774 views
    • 26 replies
    • 1310 views
    • 4 replies
    • 437 views
    • 8 replies
    • 469 views
  2. Scouting is doomed

    • 18 replies
    • 1759 views
    • 63 replies
    • 3043 views
    • 78 replies
    • 4188 views
    • 15 replies
    • 1228 views
    • 72 replies
    • 3114 views
    • 3 replies
    • 408 views
  • LATEST POSTS

    • I appreciate where you're coming from but I do believe that scout parents can be just as aggressive and demanding - if not more so - than any sports parents ever could.  In my own experience, as an Eagle Scout and as a parent of two Eagle Scouts who are both athletes, I have experienced some minor 'politics' in terms of their competing in sports, but that pales in comparison to the level of pettiness and egotism that I have seen displayed first hand by multiple scout leaders. I've also heard too many similar accounts from other scout parents, as well as posts on this board, over how some troops choose to operate by adding requirements or using their own subjective, or judgmental, biases to deny rank advancement.  I can only go by my own personal experience and I've only seen true pettiness and egotism in scouts, not in sports.
    • Really?  I've known quite a few.  It seems to me that, if scouting had little risk of long-term negative consequences, there would be no YP training.  It wouldn't be necessary.  YP training is necessary because there is a risk. I think, perhaps, it is more fun and glamorous for us old folks to complain of our old football injuries.  It is a statistical fact that there are more old people of my generation who claim to have old sports injuries than there were athletes when we were young.    Funny how that happens.    
    • I'd beg to differ here. Scouts does very much mandate participation. All troops do require a minimal level of participation to demonstrate that they are "active." "Active participation" is loosely defined by the BSA intentionally so that units can determine what level of participation is required. Troops vary greatly in this. Some are very strict and demanding of meeting attendance and camping participation, whereas others are more lax, but scouts who fall short of their troop's participation standards do not get the opportunity to advance, just like an athlete who does not attend practice regularly will not have the opportunity to play.
    • I'd be interested in hearing specific ideas that packs & troops have done that have resulted an in increased draw for Scouting.  Where have you faced losses to sports and other activities, done something to address that, and been successful? Thanks in advance
    • This is a very anti-sports article and many of the criticisms can also be applied to scout parents as easily as they could to sports parents
  • Who's Online (See full list)

×