skeptic

Certainly an issue with ours, sadly. We continue to flounder with most of the things noted not in clear use, and some missing for the most part. Volunteers, even those of us that have struggled in the past, are frustrated and we are not able to get clarity and straight info, or so it seems. Our Council board President assures us they are working on this, but it is very slow, just smoke and mirrors. I hope it is not the latter. Meanwhile, our only viable camp is shuttered, and the SE has insulted so many unit and district volunteers that the list is likely pages long. Will be interesting to see if some ideas to fix may show, but frankly, it is unclear if we have a way around the SE.

Just about my favorite poem. It, along with Crossing the Bar more and more come to mind for some reason. Both of course relate to getting old and entering that unknown.

Anyone caring to dig a bit, and have an open mind to look beyond the surface can discover indicators that BP's early efforts were more military focussed, but fairly soon changed to working to guide the youth of the time to be better citizens. Similarly, a close look at the BSA in the teens into the run up to WWII certainly show a similar emphasis, though obviously colored by the period in history. The serious and willing historians for the the program seem to have evolved to the concept of citizenship and responsibility and away from the direct military focus of some of the earliest knockoffs. Lost to many is the societal respect of Scouting, especially in BSA in the first half century or so. Chivalry and simple respect somehow fell by the wayside for some reason in many places, and the foolish "insult" of calling someone "such a Boy Scout" gained traction for some reason over time, and the concepts that are the foundation of Scouting fell into limbo of some type. Yet who, with any basic concern for others and our society could seriously say the tenets of Scouting are somehow bad? If just the Oath and Law were seen as important in broader society, we would have far fewer issues. JMHO of course, and I will be 80 soon.

It is often difficult to admit much of what we did then, prior to the seventies during the high point of Scouting participation was a bit dangerous. But most of us also were pretty aware it was. Still, helmets for bikes, seatbelts, not riding in the back of open trucks, and swimming in n inspected water all were more dangerous than we realized. On the other hand, that very thing made us more aware of our surroundings and challenged us to deal with obversities at times. But the concept that somehow we can make life, and its living, completely safe and sanitary is ignorant. Time again for my favorite stance; Balance along with the concept of Common Sense.

Did they drum up any new members?

Sadly, most likely would get hit by local health authority.

Yes, that was my intent. Sorry. We have chosen to no longer do the Popcorn, as it is NOT a good look due to the prices and such. Also, with YP, keeping scouts in front of stores and so on is challenging should we say? Thank you.

They cannot do that, period. They might though not allow a unit to participate IF they do other stuff too. But, the unit, as long as it is within the rules of National fund raising, can choose whatever they prefer. Now dealing with such a demand is dicy I would guess, but if you have a strong unit with good support, you can suggest some sand pounding I believe, but in a Scoutlike way.

Fine lines exist on how to challenge young people, or even adults. Many, likely most, would not be damaged by once common stunts like the snipe hunt. But, in the modern era, too many youth are unprepared for even a small amount of teasing, and too many parents overreact to it when it occurs. Society will not protect us from our own mental challenges and fears. Care needs to be taken, but much of that is the so called responsible adult being aware if someone is showing stress and removing them from the focus at a minimum, and maybe reviewing things with other adults and even the youth. It is often a judgment call, but awareness, as noted, by those in charge should always be a part of the issues. One of my favorite concepts; Balance.

Some irony here. I have been trying to update my YP off and on now for a few weeks. I use Chrome most of the time, but it will not work at all for some reason, even after assuring the background is cleaned out. Got on earlier using Edge, which I do not prefer. It locked up, and now I am in limbo with the first retake segment. Of course, it should have worked with Chrome, and the hangup is just very annoying. Yet, I get an email about my renewal needed constantly. Guess I will try again later.

As long as individuals or groups try to paint a picture of Child Sexual Abuse in the BSA that is not the truth, then these untruths will continue to be called out. Absolutely true; and the premise plays both directions.

It seems to me that the horse, has been beat until it is no longer even good for the glue factory. Perhaps we can work on doing our best to stop it from happening. There still cannot ever be absolutes, and if it does happen, the response needs to also follow the guidelines, and work to punish the actual perpetrator, and holding any who bent to pressure to overlook or something to accountability.

Thus what we call "thorns and roses" after events at times, especially larger ones. Trying to get the youth to speak can be hard much of the time, as we have a society that tends to NOT encourage them to speak their minds, but with candor and verity. So, they simply glare or look confused. Then, later, someone speaks up out of the circle, so to speak. We should still take that into consideration, and even maybe draw out some more. Always the challenge, but that is part of the job description I think.

That is a great poem. Another old one that I like still is Kipling's If. Growing up in the late forties and early fifties, our Mom read to my brother and I out of Cook's One Hundred and One Famous Poems. I still have that copy of the book, along with other examples, as it was in print for decades, and I think still is in a modified format. Kipling of course was part of the B.P.'s influence for Cubbing. I do not remember for sure, but I believe there is mention that B.P. was friends with Kipling.

I fudged my Nature merit badge in 1959, I think. It grated on my conscious, and later I earned completely Soil and Water, Forestry, and worked on Wildlife Management. I also did insect study. Outside of Scouts, I took a summer school class in biology that I did not need to take, but felt it would also salve my disappointment in myself. It was not just learning about nature and so on, but about myself. Self reflection can be good for you, and as an adolescent, it is even more important perhaps. Another reason we should, in my view, mentor bad behaviour in a way that might allow the youth to do that self analysis.

I find your discussion astute, and agree that age is, as many say, just a number. Of course, in parts of the world that number in regard to youth is varied in its validity for some involvements. In over fifty years in Scouting, more than 45 as an adult, I have had the pleasure of meeting many fine youth and even mentored a fair share, or I hope so. Part of that has been as happened sitting on local Eagle boards, likely at least fifteen or so. Also attended numerous Eagle dinners of recognition and visited with Eagles of all ages, from 13, completed just short of that age, to actually home from college. while the older youth were more on point overall, I still remember one that was just barely 13 at his board. His responses were more focused and mature than most of the many older youth on whose boards I sat. You never know, and to simply use age, or for that matter, gender as your only guideon is foolish in my view. We need to build on these young minds and challenge them, no matter. My generation has not done a good job for the most part, and it is sadly reflected in our societal woes. Thus, Scouting's survival and reincarnation, if you will, is imperative, and age and gender should NOT be a major factor.

Actually, it is mostly more elderly or seasoned males, seemingly unable to get out of the ruts of the past. Of course, rereading some of the historical material on B.P. shows that he was open from the early period to a program for girls, and it was always a work in progress for he and his wife. On the other hand, I have had seen some nuance that older women also have issue to a larger extent than younger. In the end, they are youth, and they all deserve the challenges Scouting in its pure form offers, no matter the chromosomes. JMHO of course.

Well this is a media platform and really a bit misleading. First, she has yet to finish the advancement, if the article is accurate. Secondly, we have no idea, other than the vague mention of bias towards her being female, as to what her experiences actually have been. Is she close to 13? What activities has her unit done? What is her experience outside of Scouting? Is she a prodigy of some kind, or just driven? The comments about some older people being rude and condescending are sad, but again out of context. We really do not know how they came about, or how many actually occurred. So, lets take a breath and see what the final outcome is, and more importantly if she completes it all, she stays with the program and contributes to others reach goals. The young woman that sort of started this push, Sydney Ireland, is now a college graduate; "I’m a recent Amherst College graduate from New York City interested in how psychology influences politics and law. I have a deep interest in contemporary dance and choreography. Since I was eleven years old, I successfully advocated for the inclusion of young women in the Boy Scouts of America. I am a member of the Inaugural class of female Eagle Scouts. In the Spring semester of 2022, I studied abroad at the University of Cambridge, Pembroke College. I just completed an internship at the White House in the Office of Communications. " The reality is that girls and boys are generally equally able to do most things, though some may be harder due to physical limitations. It is no longer really an issue, other than the hype on the age, and we all know of a few boys that we kind of wonder about, and that actually likely are shallow representatives. Give it a chance and see how she is ten years down the road.

That may be; but we also may be only seeing the tip of the proverbial iceberg. Also comparatively, the percent of verified abuse in relation to the total number of scouts is very small statistically. Still, there is an ongoing challenge, and many errors and simply stupid decisions have been noted. It is a little scary, but we can only "Do Our Best".

our view, and your right. Biased and skewed by circumstance, but your issue in that regard. I wish there was a way for your pain and hate to be lessened. But that is not something any of us can do, nor is there enough money to do it either. The realities of a warped society and human weakness cannot be remedied, but only protected against as well as possible. Recognition of reality is not the same as condoning bad actions.

Okay, finally we can see apparent proof that the BSA issue is part of the larger problem in our country, and probably most of the world if other countries mirror us in some manner. I was called names and worse when I tried to point out that BSA was being singled out while a greater problem likely exists throughout the youth serving agencies. https://www.businessinsider.com/sexual-abuse-schools-inappropriate-student-teacher-relationship-predators-2023-12 So, while there still is no excuse for what was sensationalized in regard to BSA, much that was poorly documented or exaggerated by media hype, we find a far larger concern still being glossed over. Who is doing the glossing, the authorities, school districts, and others for a myriad of reasons. I suspect if someone is able to find the documentation, child sports and other youth outreaches fall into this sad issue. The saddest part though is that it is not new, nor will it go away, no matter how upset we can get. Bad people exist in the larger populace and find ways to take advantage and hide behind legal and insurance walls. IF this article is close to accurate, it seems that the lack of cooperation of agencies when asked for records and such is worse than the BSA problem as far as scale. Reality is that MOST educators DO NOT prey on their students, but strive to enlighten them and protect them. The darker segments of humanity are real, and it needs to be recognized while not discounting that MOST mentors, whether in Schools, Youth Groups, Churches, or sports are NOT predators and try very hard to improve the lives of children. JMHO of course.

This concept being a major piece of the Scouts BSA program is, or should be, a given. BSA was integral from the start of the the Conservation awareness in the early teens. Its primary U.S. founders were all outdoor and nature supporters, though some had odd ideas in relation to today. Seton particularly was a proponent of much of the modern leanings, and I suspect if he were alive today would be on the more radical side of the movements. And even Roosevelt, it seems to me, had a direction change in his approach to nature and the natural resources. Burroughs and Hornaday also supported BSA early on. So, from my perspective, this is basic to our returning, with modern knowledge and options, to real conservatorship and support of the natural world, without which we will sooner disappear as a species.

Finding the alumni is only helpful if they choose to get involved or if they donate with a purpose, one that is noted before they do it. On a National level, we can hark back a bit to the the discussion a while back about the English Scouter Bear something (I am old and forget). At the 2010 Jambo we had Mike Rowe. To me we should be working with his group to point youth towards regular jobs, as well as portraying Scout Spirit. I could easily see a cooperative at camps that would focus on such things. Before our local council stabbed us all with mothballing camp, we had had a number of years with welding being a huge success, even seeing a couple of those youth go into it as profession. Before the idiocy recently, we a camp staff that had created automotive maintenance as a partner to welding, but that somehow disappeared, though the counselor, also a Scouter with a troop, is offering the badge at merit badge gatherings. The science related badges at camp have huge popularity and I can see a similar likelihood with the trade oriented subjects. Another direction might be working with local colleges and universities to establish stations at camps or research and also connected to merit badges. A great example of that is the Oceanography program at Emerald Bay, though I think we may be seeing that go away from recent data. It seems still to be the right direction for modern programming. A final one would be a solid cooperative interaction with the National Park Service and Forestry stations. We offered Fire Safety at camp, and it always included the Forest Service with their equipment and demos. There is nothing wrong with building those types of of interactions. It might even include the Y or heaven forbid, even the Girl Scouts. But, cooperation seems to not be something too many see as a positive. Just look at Congress.

And, the reality that "justice" is not a finite concept and ambiguous for the most part. Those harmed or at least feeling harmed always will say "justice" is not served, no matter what. Our legal system is such that the lawyers can play games for decades in some cases, certainly for months at least, and whatever happens, "justice" is not served for somebody, and the balance of Her scales will not be therre.

Only some time and patience will tell. I see some concern in finding new directions, not only for fund raising, which is an absolute, but also pointing at the inclusion of modern tech, as the youth now understand to some level, to open the program, while also mentioning aspects of the outdoors as being important. New and old can, and really must, be married. And, somehow we need to find that positive interface with the public again. My experience is that it is there, just in a hibernation mode, if you will. When we have our rag tag group in public, we seldom het any negative feedback, rather mostly positive. And that is now coming again from younger adults, not just the elderly. These people appear to appreciate young people showing patriotism and doing positive community things. We can continue to rue the mistakes and poor choices or find a new direction. Some it appears do not countenance that direction, or simply are too jaded. This may be a start, or it may again fall flat. Lets hope as the next new year looms, it will move in the positive direction. Live the Twelve, and set the examples.