Jump to content

Open Discussion - Program

Share Scouting Topics here.

Subforums

  1. Scouts with Disabilities

    Where parents and scouters go to discuss unique aspects to working with kids with special challenges.

    712
    posts
  2. Going to the next Jamboree?

    A place to chat about Scouting's biggest gathering

    2758
    posts

8913 topics in this forum

    • 5 replies
    • 189 views
    • 112 replies
    • 6154 views
    • 10 replies
    • 811 views
    • 32 replies
    • 10071 views
    • 265 replies
    • 12230 views
    • 182 replies
    • 8577 views
    • 29 replies
    • 1337 views
    • 33 replies
    • 666 views
  1. Where would you go?

    • 76 replies
    • 1933 views
    • 5 replies
    • 150 views
  2. Voice of the Scout surveys

    • 19 replies
    • 360 views
    • 19 replies
    • 225 views
    • 7 replies
    • 126 views
    • 18 replies
    • 539 views
    • 25 replies
    • 1013 views
  • LATEST POSTS

    • Sorry to append to my own post.  From the article, I think she's a member of Suffolk County Council.  On their website, they have an Eagle Scout Preparation Guide.  It's at: https://www.sccbsa.org/files/21999/Eagle-Scout-Preparation-Guide In there, the only reference to Eagle Boards of Review says: So I have to imagine that she properly filed the application.  Wither the council isn't forwarding the application or their district advancement committee is following instructions and not scheduling the board of review. I wasn't aware of rule 8.0.0.2 quoted in the article.  It says: Later in 8.0.3.0 Particulars for the Eagle Scout Rank   Her argument appears technically correct.  If the BSA wanted a special exception for girls, then they should have rewritten all of this.  
    • I am sure that the rule is all about insurance and risk mitigation.  If someone is helping a Scout on an Eagle service project and gets hurt, then they could sue the BSA.  It doesn't matter if the person who gets hurt is a member of the BSA or not.
    • I was mistaken.  Doesn't make it not a stupid rule.  I would hate to have had to plan my project around as many people as I did plus getting two, over 21, registered adults there the entire time as well.   What is dumb would be that my project was completed over about 8 days of work.  Who decides which of those days were activities and which weren't? Only 2 had other scouts there.  Man, now I feel like an old man shaking my fist at a cloud...
    • Agreed.  It would strike me that these are the key passages: I have to imagine that the valid ways to delay a EBOR are: 1. The council advancement committee declares the process is that they schedule them and then decide not to schedule one for girls who request them. 2. The council does not verify the application because she is a girl From the rules I see, these are the only valid ways I could find.  
    • The Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook (screenshot below) and the Guide to Advancement both say that Eagle Scout projects are Scouting activities and all Guide to Safe Scouting rules apply (including YPT, two-deep leadership, etc.).
       
  • Who's Online (See full list)

×