Jump to content

Venturing Program

Meet people from other Venture Crews and discuss program.

629 topics in this forum

  1. Modern scouting a For-profit business 1 2 3

    By baggss,
    • 37 replies
    • 10.1k views

  2. Train Train Train train <rant>

    By baggss,
    • 12 replies
    • 3.7k views

  3. Degrees at University of Scouting 1 2 3

    By EagleScout441,
    • 30 replies
    • 9.4k views

  4. New Venturing awards announced 1 2

    By click23,
    • 20 replies
    • 6.1k views

  5. McLaren Kilts 1 2

    By ssullivansr,
    • 19 replies
    • 5.4k views

  6. How to start a Crew? 1 2 3

    By Khaliela,
    • 30 replies
    • 7.6k views

  7. Changes to Official Venturing Uniform?

    By NJRBSA88,
    • 14 replies
    • 3.8k views

  8. Venturing on a shoestring 1 2

    By baggss,
    • 16 replies
    • 4.4k views

  9. Venturing Mentor Pin 1 2

    By SR540Beaver,
    • 17 replies
    • 6.2k views

  10. Venturing YPT Adult Leadership Training for Troop 1 2

    By Mike Krasko,
    • 16 replies
    • 5k views

  11. When can my daughter join Venturing? 1 2

    By howarthe,
    • 15 replies
    • 4.3k views

  12. Changes coming in 2014

    By Brewmeister,
    • 13 replies
    • 3.8k views

  13. OA and Venturing 1 2 3

    By EagleScout441,
    • 33 replies
    • 8.6k views

  14. Is BSA trying to kill Venturing? 1 2 3 4 6

    By dhendron,
    • 79 replies
    • 17.8k views

  15. Venture Crew supervision Question

    By jpstodwftexas,
    • 13 replies
    • 3.7k views

  • LATEST POSTS

    • Tron
      What standard for completing requirements do you use?

      By Tron · Posted

      I think GSUSA is killing themselves with the school grade bands for rank advancement. 
    • Eagle94-A1
      What standard for completing requirements do you use?

      By Eagle94-A1 · Posted

      Thanks for the updated stats.   You are correct.. Don't ask about recruiting outside of school round ups and talks. We do them, and most boys interested in what we do are already in Scouts. And those troop are catching on to focusing on adventure, not advancement. I have recruited more girls for the girls troop. One Girl Scout said she wished her GSUSA troop would do some of the stuff we do. When I mentioned the girls troop she said, " My mom would kill me. She works for the Girl Scouts."
    • Tron
      What standard for completing requirements do you use?

      By Tron · Posted

      The stat is 90% of eagle scouts came out of cub scouting. The number of scouts bsa members that came out of cub scouting is 70% (last time I saw the numbers).  Are you saying you have a troop of 7? 
    • Eagle94-A1
      What standard for completing requirements do you use?

      By Eagle94-A1 · Posted

      Depends upon circumstances. My unit follows the program, retains Scouts, even long after they earn Eagle in some cases. We have an active program that the Scouts pick. Adults do not force them to do an activity they do not want to do.  But we have no feeder pack, and have not in at least 15 years. Troop always had transfers into it. Out of the 7 on my charter, 5 transferred from other troops, and 1 had his older brothers transfer into it.  And the troop has survived by having an active, Scout-led program since before I transferred 7 years ago. I cannot find the stat now, but last time I checked 90+% of Scouts move up from Cub Scouts. And usually troops die within 6 years of packs folding.  The other troop without a pack has not had one in 5 years, and they may be folding. The 2 troops with packs have wised up, and started imitating us. Not only do they jealously guard their Cub Scout packs, they are now retaining their Scouts. One of those troops, is the one I transferred from. I almost had 1/2 the troop transfer with me, until the COR stepped in. And in my neck of the woods, lack of Cub Scout recruiting is the #1 reason units are folding.
    • Eagle94-A1
      What standard for completing requirements do you use?

      By Eagle94-A1 · Posted

      You do know that the research for "OPERATION FIRST CLASS," "First Class, First Year," or whatever it is called now is deeply flawed? The research was done in the 1980s, and the idea came out in August 1989. That's  when they did away with Skill Awards, time requirements for Tenderfoor, Second Class, and First Class, and went from "Master the Skills," to "The Badge represents what a Scout CAN DO (SIC), not what he has done." mentality which IMHO leads to "One and Done." Research showed that Scouts who got First Class in 18 months stay around longer, which is true. BUT what was not included in the stats was 2 things: 1.How active a unit is and 2. LDS units. The more active a troop is, doing the activities the Scouts want to do, will lead to  retention. Yes advancement is slower, but those Scouts stick around longer. Best example is my soon to be 21 y.o. ASM.  He spent 4 years working on First Class as the swimming requirement was the issue. But the troop dis activities he liked, and he stuck around. He eventually passed the swim test, and earned Eagle. He has stuck around as much as possible while in college.  And all of my Eagles have stuck around until 18, or until they started college. Why? Because we are active and do the activities they want to do. But  the surveyors dis not show how active a troop was in their results.   The LDS units would segregate their 11 year old Scouts. I have seen lesson plans where the 11 year old patrol would repeat the same program every year. They were treated as if they were still Cub Scouts, with an ASM serving more as a DL, and TGs acting more like  den chiefs. Their program guaranteed them First Class in one year. One reason why LDS units got upset when the Camping requirement for First Class  went from 4 camp outs to 6 campouts in 2016: their 11 year olds were not allowed to camp more than 4 times /year.  And their protest changed it back to 4 (aside this ticked off my middle son as he had to wait 2 months to get the 6 campouts in, and right as he goes for his First Class BOR, National changed it back to 4. He was ticked off) And since the LDS used Scouting as their youth program, ALL (emphasis) males were registered in their troops, whether they were active or not. That skewed the data. So do not take the First Class, First Year to seriously. If you push it, you will have Scouts get bored, note care, leave, or stick around long enough to get Eagle and then quit. I have seen this happen with a lot over the years.  
×
×
  • Create New...