Jump to content

Eagle94-A1

Members
  • Posts

    4983
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    145

Everything posted by Eagle94-A1

  1. Lots of good answers. A few more: When family obligations start taking a back seat to your Scouting addiction, it may be time to hand it in. When it's time to move along to another stage,i.e going from CS to BS, or as one SM is doing, BS to Venturing, it may be time to hand it in. Yep I quit one position b/c I was tired of the garbage I had to deal with. Another time it was because I didn't get the support I needed when a bad situation arose. But most time, I had to turn it in due to moves with work. Right now I'm debating turning in my CSDL badge. We got a strong pack and I know we can find a DL to replace me as I had to go back to Tigers twice before for my younger sons. As much as I want to stay with my youngest, he actually behaves better when I am not around. Yep he's the troublemaker in my den. But my oldest son's troop needs some help. The SM is getting on in years and has health issues. My wife was talking to his wife, and his wife mentioned he needs to step down. The heir apparent is back in Cubs Scouts, and may be there a while. Plus his schedule is absolutely crazy. He's on call a lot, and has missed meetings and trips because of being on call. To bad the citizens of my town won't behave.
  2. The Tiger Cub device is actually the newest one, it was created AFTER the decision to merge all three DL awards into one. And it was pointed out that there was NO (emphasis) Tiger Cub device as originally there was no need for one. So that may be why the TC device was not mentioned; it wasn't around yet when the book came out. Also, the language in the notes have not been updated to include the the CS and Webelos devices for the Den Leader Awards. So it may have been overlooked by the editors. Not the first time that national had minor errors in it. SO, wear you knot with the brand new TC Device and old CS Device on it with pride!
  3. I'm not aware of a standard size for a dance arbor. Depends upon on the number of dancers. Question: doe the 35' diameter include benches as well as dance space? I ask because 35' for dancing seems adequate, I'ld go with 50' diameter personally. But if that included benches as well dance space, I would say no. If you give me some time, I'll look up the sizes of two arbors at scout camps that I've danced in.
  4. 'Skip, May I Ripoff and Duplicate ( R&D)? That was AWESOME!
  5. "So be it" J.edi WELCOME TO THE FORUMS!
  6. I would wait until they move up in June to buy anything since everything Cub Scout changes to the new program June 1st. Or at the very earliest wait until May 1st when all the new, indepth information comes out, including books. Hopefully national learned from the fiasco that was the Centennial Uniform. I do not know if they are keeping the Tri-colors or not. But currently Webelos can wear the activity pins on the hat. BUT again that may change June 1st.
  7. What were the parents thinking? Are they out of their minds? Sorry but the parents were flat out wrong, and you have every reason to be ticked off.
  8. Yep, YPT is to protect both the youth AND adults. I know of one situation where a very experienced and good leader lost her membership because of an accusation. Long story short, she caught a "scout" being a peeping Tom by the ladies' showers after hours. When he was confronted by folks about it, he accused her of making a pass. Since it was a "He said, she said" case, national took his word over hers.
  9. Fred, I not only agree with you, but would expand it some. Depending upon the unit's leadership you are asked to serve as commissioner for, if you served with the leadership in ANY (emphasis) unit level capacity, it may take years to serve with them as a UC. You know the situation with me and my CO's troop when I was their acting UC. I was not a leader with that troop, but knew all of the current leadership via the CO's pack. Whenever I tried to help out or offer advice, I was told, "that's not how we do things in the troop," "Scouting has to change with the times," "you don't know what you are talking about," and the two - three hours of complaining about the lack of training in the DISTRICT (emphasis again) when I had to stay overnight with them because everyone left camp except the SM and 2 scouts.. That last one really broke the straw since A) the district offers SM Specific and IOLS once a year, B) council has a total of 9 opportunities each year for that training since each district is responsible for conducting their own course, and C) I specifically planned an IOLS course around THEIR troop calendar so that all of their leaders needing IOLS could get it. Only 1 showed up, the others excuse was "it's too cold to camp."
  10. Sent, I am so sorry to hear that. I know how much influence a former leader can have, for good or evil.
  11. "High Adventure" doesn't require paying someone to plan, organize and guide. If the scouts (patrols or crews) have been doing scouting adventure by planning and organizing, then doing so for the next level of high adventure is the next logical step. True, but sometimes the guides can be FUN! When I did the Canadian trip, we had a Canadian Scout troop provide us guides. We had a lot of fun, and a few years later, I was able to return the favor and be a guide for them. It saddens me that scouting has moved from scouts making their own gear, finding places to camp, and organizing their own adventures to needing to raise money to pay for expensive hi-tech stuff, and extra gadgets and paying for expensive camps and guides.1> Blame some of that on BSA legal. Some of the simplest, and lightest, equipment to make are some of the various can stoves. Heck the CS leader How To Book even had instructions on how to make them. Now they are verboten. One thing about gear and expense, yard sales, ebay, craigslist, military surplus, etc are great sources. Key is take care of the gear. As one of SPLs would say, "Take care of your gear like you would take care of your girlfriend. Treat it right and you will will have a long health relationship." Sad when an eagle scout doesn't know how to plan and organize a basic camping trip without paying someone to do it for them. A Scout is thrifty. Agree 110%.
  12. While it is possible, I would not recommend it. Sometimes folks need an "expert," i.e. someone not in the unit, to get advice from.
  13. There are local council HA bases you can go to. PAMLICO SEA BASE outside Washington, NC is one that focuses on sailing and kayaking. And there are many others. Also you can always have your troop plan their own HA trip. Appalachian Trail is popular in my neck of the woods, but also look at canoe treks and sailing cruises. As a Boy Scout, I did a 64 mile canoe trek in the Canadian wilderness. As a Sea Scout, I did a week long cruise with my ship. More work is involved in planning it, but they are cheaper.
  14. 'Gipper, I feel for ya. I actually lost a TIGER (emphasis) becasue the pack didn't camp enough for the family ( 3x/year). I know my troop did a "wilderness survival" type campout for Webelos needing an overniter to introduce them to the troop. What started out as an accident, all of our gear being destroyed and finding out the night before the overnighter, became a tradition as the WEBELOS ATE IT UP! (emphasis, ok maybe a little shouting with glee ) When I suggested that a troop do that with the incoming Webelos, one of the CS mom's freaked out and said there is no way the Webelos could do that. When I told her we use to do it every year, she looked at me like I had a thrird eye. Anotherguy, If you look at the new requirements, every level has some type of camp out is required. Don't know how the LDS units are going to del with that.
  15. By any chance, is that author William Hillcourt? I know he wrote a few non-BSA books on the topic.
  16. Mike, I saw a similar situation in HS with the JROTC unit. School wanted the school colors used during for certain events during the school year. So the color guard was expanded to 5 people instead of the usual 4. 2 rifle bearers, US Flag, USMC flag, and school flag. And with my CS pack, we've had a situation where the pack flag's stand is MIA ( that's a different story for a different time). So we uses the CO's church flag in place of the pack flag. Hopefully the troop will eventually return our stand to the pack.
  17. Let me tell you about the differences between Cub Scout camping and Boy Scout camping Seriously, as others have said Cub Scout camping is designed more for families that do not camp or do very little. Object is to get them comfortable in the outdoors and HAVE FUN! ( and yes I am screaming HAVE FUN! ) It may get a little more 'adventorous" as a Webelos as he will be preparing for Boy Scouts. The fun in the outdoors really starts as a Boy Scout when they do thinggs on your own without adults meddling about. And you can do stuff on your own. We have one dad and lad who are VERY outdoor oriented. The Webelos has already done a section of the AT and another trail! LeCastor You forgot the "G.I. JJJJOOOEEE" at the end of your comments.
  18. THANK YOU EVERYONE, the comments and recommendations have been very helpful and needed.. One update as an FYI. My son's first camp out as SPL was suppose to be tomorrow. He started feeling sick this afternoon and has a low grade fever. So he missed out on a cooking competition tonight, and will be missing the camp out tomorrow. I remember the last time a sick kid went camping and infected the entire camp! Anyway, we were talking, and he feels bad about missing out, like he is letting down his troop. I told him I would contact the SM for him, and not to worry about it. We talked some, reemphasized that he has my full support, his SMs support, and the Scouts' support. He told me his biggest concern is not doing a good job, and letting his troop down. I told him 1) he can always talk to the other adult leaders, and that he doesn't have to do everything, he can and should delegate to the other scouts. I asked him if he thought if they should include ILST at the lock in coming up, andhe said yes. I was planning on asking the SM for him as I do need to go camping,i'm the designated 2nd leader as a third is on call, but decided he can tyalk to his PLs and ask the SM Monday.
  19. Don't know. Ebay may be a source for everything together. What my son's troop did was go to the dollar store and get plastic plates and cups. We don't have the old mess kits either, but they adapted.
  20. In my 30+ years in Scouting, 1've only met 1 Varsity Scout, and he was going to jambo in 2010.
  21. If I may offer some perspective? Now I am going assume, and you know what can happen when you assume , that JP has been a leader in Scouting no earlier than 1989 as that is when the concept of an NSP, one big AOL Ceremony (although many packs were doing it that way, it wasn't intended to from my readings), and the concept of First Class, First Year ( or OPERATION FIRST CLASS as it was called) all came about in BSA literature. So for many folks, the way JP states is the only way they know. Not saying that is correct, and I am not saying it is not. More on that in a bit. Now I am going to assume, and again you know what can happen , that Stosh has been around since way before the 1989, when the norm was not NSPs, Experienced Patrols, and venture patrols, but mixed aged patrols and Leadership Corps for the senior most scouts. Scouts came into the troop, joined a patrol that was already existing and he may or may not know anyone in the troop. Not saying that is right or wrong either. Now what I am saying is a troop's program and organization MUST work for them. How the patrols are organized and work doesn't matter, only if the Scouts are getting the program. I grew up in a mixed aged patrol troop. Older scouts in the patrol buddied up with the younger scouts and worked with them. The two times NSPs were tried, were complete and utter failures, and the PLC decided to go back to the traditional organization of mixed aged patrols. And because we did not have a feeder pack during all but my last year as a youth, we were constantly getting folks into the troop year round. Since getting FCFC was non-existant, there was no emphasis on getting scouts to FC in a year. So what Stosh is describing worked for us. As an adult, I have been involved with troops that use NSPs, Experienced Patrols, and venture patrols. They have feeder packs that cross over all at once, so a more formal FCFY program can be organized.The unit culture and organization are such that that method works for them. That's what is great about scouting, as long as certain parameters are followed, there is a multitude of ways to have a program. JP, To answer your question, it depends on the Scouts and what they are doing. In 2012, all the Cubs went to the same troop, which got scouts from us only. In 2013, five Cubs went to the CO's troop, which also picked up Scouts from Spring recruiting, and 2 went to Troop B down the road. Troop B also has a feeder pack. This year, all three are going to Troop B. And we are actually doing a joint AOL/Crossover Ceremonies.
×
×
  • Create New...