qwazse

The medal is not the pinnacle. The pinnacle scouting experience is hiking and camping independently with one's mates. When a scout can be trusted to do that, he/she has arrived. Service projects are just a way of showing a scout can apply what they've been doing in their troop to help their community.

Projects like these should stretch the youth. They should be something he/she hasn't done before. They should address something important to the youth. When leaders any level come back with "also do" lists, it sounds like asking more of the same. It may be in a direction that doesn't inspire the youth. It may be nothing the beneficiary really wants. The project should be the first of several as a youth. Too much beurarcracy makes a kid want to put his/her first project off until his/her managment and presentation skills are mastered, and that's a shame.

Why should they be hard?

My gut tells me this is an honest (albeit misguided) attempt to prepare the next generation for the "real world" scenarios experienced by the previous generation. At least around here. Plenty of guys got by with a handshake and maybe a handwritten contract. But a woman in the same profession would feel she had to come with a polished proposal and all the bells and whistles to land the same bid. Then to stay in the business, she had to outdo herself or lackluster competition would call on the good-old-boys network to grease the wheels in their favor. I hope it's not just Mash's GS council, but that nationally the "steam will be let off the pressure cooker" for these girls just a little. There's plenty of work to do in this country, and we need kids who know how to do it, one focused project after another.

Your classmates could have taken a cue from my classmates' playbook and pounce on the Arabs ... or whoever was next in line. Fact is, folks in OK are so nice it's just plain scary. I'm glad Daughter graduated a Sooner. But, every time I visited, there was just a tiny part of my coastal wiring that was on edge ... just waiting for you all to club us when our back was turned and put us in the stew pot!

I've heard this from parents of my female venturers as well.

Why two hours? How about "however long it takes to earn 1st class rank in a patrol of scouters trying to serve our youth? Mr. SPL or JASM will sign off as you demonstrate the skills." I'm really looking to get some adults out of the SM's hair for more than just a day. (Actually, this batch of adults are coming along quite nicely. A couple of them were Eagle scouts, and are really good mentors -- both of youth and parents.) P.S. - @MattR, sorry about the back pain. Ouch! Hope you bounce back before the next campout that comes your way.

@Terasec, way to take a three year old thread completely out of context. This post is about gays. Not godless or girls. Although, I daresay the appeal to debate without denigrating may still apply.

I'm indifferent. Our camp's T2FC area is well run. But, it robs PL's/APL's (not to mention TG) of their purpose. We no longer sign off on requirements just because the T2FC staff signs off that the scout was present when they were taught. (That's also the recommendation of the camp brochure.) Boys are expected to demonstrate skill mastery to their PL. Bottom line: we've gotten no more Eagles with or without First-class-first-year, so if a kid would rather knock out baskets and leatherwork than got to the T2FC area, I encourage adults to support him. We do want younger scouts to try and advance a rank at camp if they haven't done so already, but that's generally so the adults present could feel useful by holding the occasional BoR during free time or in the evening.

The king is gone, long live the king.

Rescucitating an old thread because: I'd love to hear from @MattR about how his scheme flew or flopped. If you want to spout off your great idea to the JTE task force, you have a week.Click here for instructions at Bryan's Blog. Write them. Let us know what you said. Even if they don't use it, maybe we will ... just for fits and giggles.

Most days, I'll gladly take credit where it isn't due. But, I'm just the relay. BSA's very own @RichardB takes the trouble blow his committee's horn. I just read and link to them as various threads warrant. The real statistics that I'd like to see (but are nigh impossible to collect) are long term relative risks/benefits. But, that's a different rant.

So, what's the plan for your next Palm? Are you gonna round off your MB count before your BoR so you can snag an inns ta-Palm or two?

The registration status of a leader was immaterial. In fact it could make things worse. Typically, scouters with lapsed registration are to cease all scouting activities until it is restored. So, for example, if he signed in as a registered leader for the event when he was not on the roster, it's a problem. If he then ignored G2SS age recommendations thereby putting an unprepared scout at risk, that's a bigger problem. If this is the way you all do business, that's even a bigger problem. Given the disconcerting revisions to G2SS, some of us patrol-method folks who rely on 18 y.o. ASMs are about to have tremendous problems.

Okay, not too far down from my rule #1 (never ask for a rule) is this one from Hezikiah: Don't show the Babylonians the treasury!

@Jameson76, did you all get trip cancellation insurance?

Well, at least you didn't derail the entire subject by dinging the troop on the lack of compliance with Flag Code 36.176.c.

Well, they probably don't think they are aweful. I suspect that these boys aren't in the honor guard for much besides the parade. Thus, the lack of interest in the patch.

@bearess, this sounds like our typical rogue troop. (I know of one such troop in our council.) Sometimes these troops register their girls through GS/USA or some other organization, but everything else is a Boy Scout program. Others don't register their girls at all until they turn 14. Evidently there are enough such troops out there, that giving them legitimacy seems worthwhile.

Welcome, and thanks for all you do for our youth.

Eight, -- floods were first.

From time to time, we've had scouts join asking questions about rank advancement. Not sure if which, if any of them, reported getting their bird. We've had a few young Eagles ask "what's next?" But @ItsBrian, you're the odd duck who feels that strangers on the internet are worthy of a play-by-play.

How strange. We always seem to get a set of boys who have opposite interests (typically heavy sports/karate vs. heavy scouts). I don't think our pack ever turned away a brother from the occasional event. But, if he made regular appearances, we'd hand him an application and say, "Why not?" Our venturing crew considered a $5 surcharge for "guests", which would be used to pay rechartering fees and the youth's registration if they came frequently enough. That thinned the herd quickly.

So, what have you done with male siblings who aren't registered and don't want to be?

Welcome to the forums. Only one temporary insignia may be worn over the right pocket of the uniform shirt. Some folks (i.e. me) will sew one insignia on the pocket and hang another from the button. But that;'s not proper uniforming. If you want to display multiple patches, get a brag vest.