Jump to content

TAHAWK

Members
  • Content Count

    4183
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    61

Everything posted by TAHAWK

  1. Mr. Fox, the Scxouter, has posted this: [Paragraphs created. Spelling as in original]
  2. In the UK and the U.S., Scouting from the first was traditionally character and citizenship development, the second being inclusive of leadership development. Also, Scouting from the first has aimed at achieving the physical and mental development of boys: good people and good citizens who are sound in mind and body. We know this because the leaders of Scouting have consitently said so for 107 years. While emphasizing the importance of the spiritual, Scouting has never presented itself as religious training. On the contrary, religious training is expressly left to religions. The othe
  3. SM Bob, but for the Scoutmasters, the scam would not be possible. The staff knows the candidates are not earning the MBs: "You pretend to give me a job I can do; I pretend to do it." The Council execs know it's wrong, are sworn to do it right, but deliberately break the rules. B.S.A. Corporate knows it's wrong and allows it to happen. The kids know they didn't earn the MBs but almost everyone else tells them "great job," so it must be OK. (Happily, I have had a number come to me after getting the Blue Card signed to work on the MB. THEY should be in charge.) Say it aga
  4. Absolutely not required. However, here is a course where the students do not even touch the text, are not tested, but all get an "A." "Traditional values"
  5. No sense singling out the camp or council since it's a wide-spread practice at council summer camps to deliberately violate the rules for many Merit Badges. The councils know what they are doing. I have written acknowledgement from B.S.A. Corporate that this is a known practice and have received no indication of any plan - or will - to correct it. 2014 Summer Camp evidenced no change from all but one prior experience since 1981 in council camps in five states. It's a long-standing practice. The practice? All Merit Badges in Scoutcraft and Citizenship areas again given out without ind
  6. The senior Senator from Iowa is looking into the matter. New tune: Not sure I'd say it quite like this: CBP has denied media access to the video that it says exonerates the agent from the claim of drawing his pistol. Prelude to hard drive crash? ​ CBP has also declined to supply copy of statute that it says authorizes no photographing rule. Well, they doubtless have a pen and telephone.
  7. We already have the UNTRAINABLE patch. Won;t that do? ^___^ __________________________ Which "uniform"?
  8. Assuming it went down as described - boy picture agent gun seizure of camera threats, its fairly ugly. This seems accurate: See also: http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/Sharp_ltr_5-14-12.pdf So we have a person acting under color of law depriving a citizen - or two - of his Constitutionally-protected rights by threat of lethal force. That would be a civil wrong and possibly a criminal offense. A Google search of boy scout border canada alaska agent gun camera = 329,000 hits
  9. Your "juggernaut" quote is from SFGate.com, writing before the Court journalized its final judgment. As the quoted language from the Court shows, the Court held that BSA had acquired a right to the trademarks as a matter of law before the Charter. "From before 1916 when the charter was passed, the strength of the Boy Scout's marks had been established as a matter of law. Again, the court in Adolph Kastor explained that the Federal Trade Commission had already found that "the words 'Scout" and "Scouting" had acquired a secondary meaning as applied to the Boy Scouting movement. 138 F.2
  10. Really hard, at the least. We had four - what shall I call them? - non theist participants at NYLT this year (Jains and Buddhists) and it lengthened the time that had be devoted to come up with a program that was "spiritual" but not offernsive to the theists.
  11. The Court in Wrenn held that the BSA's rights, as I noted, arose from trademark law AND the charter. Further, the court held that the riights arising under trademark law predated the Charter. "From before 1916 when the charter was passed, the strength of the Boy Scout's marks had been established as a matter of law. Again, the court in Adolph Kastor explained that the Federal Trade Commission had already found that "the words 'Scout" and "Scouting" had acquired a secondary meaning as applied to the Boy Scouting movement. 138 F.2d at 825." . . . "[This status was] in addition to the
  12. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._McRaven
  13. Comment: They do that quite frequently. They just fought a legal battle with SCOTUS over their desire to discriminate against the religious owners of Hobby Lobby, in violation of a statute signed into law by President Clinton. They have ended contracts with Catholic adoption agencies over their commitment to abide by their religious beliefs. Reply: No, the Catholic adoption agencies ended the contracts, because the government would not grant those contracts to agencies that excluded gays as potential adopters. Those agencies could have either agreed to the contracts, or continued with
  14. Our Council demoted the Camp Director who was running a Merit Badge Mill. After nearly two yeasr as a jr.-level DE, they fired him outright. He had other problems. The mill is running full blast at another Council's camp. "Change Camp Directors" Sounds good. Why stop there? Ending pain, suffering, and evil would also be good.
  15. A. After trying to work with the camp and its council and being told they can't afford to follow the rules, I am working with National. B. Which point of the Law leads you to "It's un-scout-like [sic] to complain"? C. Adults can counsel but do not determine what camp the PLC selects. D. "Some" Merit Badges are given reather than being earned. E. If a camp cannot afford to adequately staff for the number of candidates they accept, how does that support the conclusion that they are entited to cheat? I'll bet you can think of alternatives. Look! You did. But as I noted,
  16. Sure. They can recycle. Also, what is not "disposable"? Look in the L&F at the end of Summer Camp nad see what gets disposed of. (It's the single boots that get me.)
  17. Indeed they do. In all cases, "could" needs to be empowered by "may." My home council has the advancement Committee organize Counselors on a rotating basis so the candiate to Counselor ratio is more like 5/1 Plus, the candidiates are told to arrive prepared to be tested on designated requirements - most of the requirements in fact. This council for this camp has no Advancement Committee. They were stunned when I asked to help ("How?") This place has no process to allow Counselors to function to supplement, much less replace, the non-Counselors. They will let you watch - even
  18. Just learned Summer Camp where PLC decided to go has 45 candidates for Wilderness Survival and one "counselor" in three sessions That gives him about eighteen minutes per candiate for instruction and testing - only there will undoubtedly be no testing + time for shelter-building, such as it will be. I wonder if the "counselor" is, in fact, a Counselor. They had a Counselor for that MB but he had to leave after first four weeks, so ?????.
  19. I've heard this song before. It is a crashing bore. I would not shed a tear If I heard it nevermore.
  20. Rant follows. As National Council knows, many council camps do not enforce requirements for some Merit Badges. EXAMPLE: "class" of forty+ Scouts listen to lectures on First Aid MB topics for 250 minutes in the heat of Summer and, with no individual testing and even if unconscious for part of 250 minutes, all get MB. EXAMPLE: 40+ Scouts listen to lestures on WIlderness Survival (Often inaccurate: bear bag is made of special cloth so bears cannot smell contents), build functionally useless shelter (can be seen through from any angle), start three fires without using match (buta
  21. Sort of like hailing a polite armed robber. NYT is proudly left-wing. That's OK. Others are proudly right-wing. I'd like to find "Proudly Objective." That NYT is clearly not. PLEASE ask for examples. However, the fact is that the right was disproportionately targeted, all right groups were denied certification, all but one left group was certified. So you are accurate - and ignoring the truth at the same time. Sort of like NYT hailing fall in unimployment while ignoring fall in absolute and relative numbers of the employed and increase of those on public assistance. (Those not act
×
×
  • Create New...