Jump to content

mdutch

Members
  • Content Count

    345
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by mdutch

  1. In general, I agree with OGE. The librarian should keep the list of who has what book, and who has returned it. If they have a problem with people returning matirials, they should confront it immediatly. Someone should not be denyied rank advancemnt because they are currently using a troop book.

     

  2. Up until about a month ago, I was a regular on this forum. I have slowly stopped coming here over the past month, and now it is time for me to say good bye for a while.

    For those of you who don't know me, I am a life scout and SPL of my troop. However, I have been accepted to be a Page in the US Senate. This will take me off to Washington DC for 5 months, so I wont have much activity (here, or anywhere else online).

     

    Good bye, thanks for all the hlep and advise all of you have given me, and I hope to return someday soon.

     

    -Eric

  3. It does seem to be a wood badge patrol. Doing a google search, I think that wood badge course was offered by the Colonial Virginia Council. If you want to try getting in touch with them, contact the council,

    11721 Jefferson Ave.

    Newport News, VA 23606-1935

    Phone: 757-595-3356

     

     

  4. With few exceptions, it is Mr./Mrs. Lastname. I think it is a harder adjustment for some of the adults (including our soon to be SM) than it is for us scouts. Afterall, we are used to refering to adults that way from being in school (I can only think of 1 teacher in our school who is refered to by first name, partly because her last name is Smith (and their are myltiply Mrs. Smith's) and partly as a sign of disrespect).

    The only exception to this would be one of our former SM's, no sons in the troop, former SPL (15 years ago). He was always refered to by first name.

  5. I'm not sure if this is true or not, but couldn't an ASM serve on a Eagle BOR for a scout in a different troop. After all, the only requirment for them is that they understand the significance of the rank and the scout oath and law.

     

    Not sure if this is allowed, just a thought

  6. Interesting situation. I would try to find out more about what his beliefs are before I made a decision. What if he says that he believes in god, but also believes that communication with god should be done individually, not publicly (leading your patrol in grace). Would that be concidered grounds for waiving the requirment? If so, by whom?

  7. I think the key to the situation is the fact that the scouts asked you to take a less hands on approach. If they decided it was important enough to ask you to do this, then I would listen to them. They, better than anyone here, know how much help they need. However, make sure you continue to give feedback, and to let them know that you are their to help if they need it.

     

     

  8. A few year ago my troop started an annual "mystery trip". Briefly, what it is is a trip where the destination is not announced until we arrive at the location. We do the trip at the end of april break from school, Thursday through Sunday. In the past we have gone to places like Washington DC(smithsonian, navel acadamy), Boston (science museum, USS Massachusets), and Valley Forge/Hershey.

     

    What I was hoping to get from this group is some ideas of other places we could go to. We are located in Albany, NY. So it would probably need to be

  9. Make sure you know something about the unit before you present to them. Try to answer the following question:

    What service that MY TROOP USES is provided by the council, that could be lost if money for FOS is not raised.

     

    The last time we had someone come in to do a FOS pitch to our troop he spent a good amount of time talking about how the council needs money to run there great summer camp programs. He didn't realize that we haven't been to in council summer camp in a long time (atleast the past decade).

  10. Great Story! My thought as I was reading it was what happens at the BoR. My guess is that most of the board members will not know all the details of his experiences that you have seen, and from your explination, he might not have realized this yet himself.

    Any thoughts on if he will have problems passing a Board of Review for a lack of leadership?

  11. I'm looking for this for my new Venturing Crew. while a couple of us are also boy scouts, most of the crew has no idea what size portions you should make (everything from how many loafs of bread for sandwhiches, to how many pounds of pasta for spaghetti dinner and everything in between).

  12. I am too tired right now (just got back from Camporee) to give a long response, so I might expand on this later.

     

    Most of the advise that I could give you, would be a repeat of what has already been said in other threads. I agree with pretty much all of Greying Beaver said.

    However, one piece of advise that i will give you now, is be prepared to recieve the following response when you bring it up the the committee or SM:

    "What we are doing now works, why change it"

     

    Not sure how to answer that, but just something to think about.

     

    YiS,

    Eric

  13. I agree with what Hunt said. The plain reading of the requirment makes it seem like time spent as ASPL or SPL doesn't count towards requirment one. I also agree that that is completly unreasonable, and unfair. So, for the purposes of that requirment, I concider myslef in the "senior patrol" which acts only to give the SPL/ASPLs a place to be in.

×
×
  • Create New...