Jump to content

Its Me

Members
  • Content Count

    573
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Its Me

  1. Why do so many of you want to demonize Woodbadge? Its a training program to assist adults in delivering a fun-filled youth oriented outdoor program. My post above was an attempt to demonstrate that a good Boy Scout program is more than just Pioneering skills. Scouting is a complicated program. It has advancements (customized to meet the interests of individual scouts), boy leadership balanced with adult association, off-site campouts, meal planning community service, "ideals of character" and religious involvement. A lot must be understood to deliver a solid program. (staying on
  2. You all have much stronger opinions on what Wood badge is and is not than I do. It is training for adults leaders who are implementing a youth group program. Nothing more or less. The training tries to help adults deliver a better program to the youths. I have seen first hand the very ideal scoutmaster many speak of. We were in a troop where the scoutmasters skills were extremely impressive. There wasn't a knot, plant on insect that he couldn't identify. Yet he couldn't delivery the program. He couldn't teach. He couldn't stop just showing off skills he knew. His campout p
  3. I have an MBA and the 15 week Dale Carnegie mangement course training/ All completed prior to Woddbadge. I have 20 years of industry experience and numerous 1 day, 1 hour and 2 day courses on management skills. WB21 is not a management course. They do work on some public speaking skills only because this shows up on so high on many personal fears. They are also teaching you to be a trainer for youths who will do public speaking. The communications skills, public speaking, note taking and listening techniquies are straight out of the Patrol Leaders handbook. All this is a small part
  4. Thanks Here is my program based off a PL's training pamphlet from the 1970's. I am using this old resource because I did not find the current troop training manuals sufficient in detail. Opening game / assemble game (from old book) A stake is planted in the ground. A scout about 75 from stake, takes a compass baring on the stake and then a paper bag goes over his head. He is spun three time and told to look down on his compass and find his way to the stake. Second game (from Link above) All boys are blindfolded and told to grab each others arm / hand. Now they must form
  5. Take earplugs. Next year fix the calendar at the annual planning event. If you don't and allow changes at every PLC meeting then you have a month-month calendar. You can't plan meetings and advancements oportunities at campouts on a month to month basis. At least they are planning for an event 5 months down the road. That shows initiative.
  6. I see that Camp Woodruff offers a troop canoe overnighter. This looks interesting to me. I was wondering if I could get some comments on troops who have done this specific overnighter or troops who have done their own overnighter at summer camp.
  7. As a generalization from my youth. Kids whose parents were involved in their sports and activities seemed more successful. Those kids whose parents showed up for little games played better. Kids whose parents went to watch them in the marching band at half time went to better colleges. Kids whose parents were involved in their lives seemed to get into less trouble. I don't see an inconsistency in a program that aims for good character, uses advancement and adults association as two pillar of its program and parents being involved. The child's parent is his principle teacher.
  8. I am running a leadership program this weekend for First Class scouts and above. The focus will be the Patrol Leaders Handbook. I need two 30-45 minutes games. Ideally one should be a team building game and the other a leadership game. What have you seen work well and Why?
  9. Did some one mention the obvious? Posting hundreds of times on a public forum about scouting. Checking forum daily the for new posts or replies. Discussing the minutia of what is meant by ----- in the handbook. Yes, Scouters as much we have all written and pushed into the Man-scout and woman-scout all the attributes we don't like in an adult leader, most of the posters on these forums would fall into the category of adult-scout. The threshold for man-scout move depending on the eyes looking at it. Example, the pack I just visited the cub master and assistant cub master wore blue
  10. Training would be similar to what it is now: I would break out the training program into four areas Cubs Webelos & First Class PLC / Patrol Training Venturers / Older Scouts The cub training would be a weekend event think Baloo on caffeine. This training module would focus on getting the kids and their parents into tents and into the outdoors. Outdoor skills that are too often assumed as being taught by the pack aren't. The Pack may have a few experienced camper but too often they aren't in a position where they can train parents. (sneaking this in "allow den campi
  11. Its November and NYLT is in July. I have to begin planning and preparing a scout for the week long commitment. Do I plan to send the current SPL? Do I send the SPL and ASPL assuming that one will follow the other? Our SPL was elected in October. I can see him getting re-elected in March. He will be half way through his second term by the time he gets into NYLT. Is he too late? Do I hedge and and send two? Three?
  12. That menu looks OK to me for backpacking. Kids don't crave flavor like adults so variety is not important to them. Maybe it's a little light on calories so they may want to review and see if they have a minimum of 2500 calories per day per scout (consult book for recommended value for age and weight). With all the hiking they will likely go calorie negative for a few days but if its a short trip of less than five days they will be OK. Most of my young scouts 12 and under won't even eat a beef stew. My own second class scout orders pasta with no sauce. Highly seasoned food is avoided
  13. I can see that this could consume many hours of effort and thoughts of my committee members. And it seems it would all be for naught. The old troop did have a practice of giving kids money they ~earned. One year, I am told they even passed out cash to the kids. This past year they allowed individual popcorn sales to pay off individual summer camps. One kid raised $200 in donations and this went directly to his summer camp expenses.
  14. As many may know, several parents and I formed a new troop after six months in one troop. During those six months we paid annual dues of $50, fully participated in a $750 fundraiser. One of the my kid's dad even donated $1,000 for the troop to buy a trailer. The new trailer was purchased and the small trailer was considered for sale. [Drama fill-in] Well when we announced that we were forming our own troop and would leave the troop after the court of honor in three weeks, the scoutmaster kicked us out. He said all the departing scouts should not return to any troop events and should
  15. Neither is following the program if hazing is allowed. Between the two evils I would choose Troop 1. Hazing seems the lesser of the evils and IMHO can be more easily corrected in a troop that has trained leaders. What to tell the parents? I would have a hard time even recommending that a scout go to troop 2 as they seem too far off the mark. Chances are that troop 2 is also far off the mark in advancement and leadership development. I would describe more as kid run than boy lead.
  16. Am I over-reacting in expecting more out of an eagle scout? No
  17. Its Me

    Knot Me

    I like Beavah's teacher analogy the best. Other parables I will dispute. In the military they save their medals for their dress blues. Professors don't feel the need to wear their resumes on their shoulder. Sure, Professors wear the robes and colors at commencement and they have meaning but that's only twice a year. By some analogies I should pursue every knot there is to show the kids what a go getter I am, and they should follow. FScouter wrote That's one I never heard of. And I thought I had the Insignia Guide memorized. With all do respect. That' just scary! I will
  18. Its Me

    Knot Me

    I have no knots on my shirt. I am sure I could find some way to get some but I am not sure why I need knots. I founded a troop so I guess I could have one for that. I am sure their are others I could qualify for having served as a leader for more than five years. But why? This is a youth program not an adult association club. Adult knots seem childish. Why do adults get all tied up in knots?
  19. Thanks for the post and thank you for serving as the SM. It sounds like the boys are really growing under your leadership.
  20. So we all took at the right time and someone knows someone who may have taken too early. Common on! This is the best analysis we got on when to take Woodbadge? I will say that taking it 3 years into a troop is too late. Three years of working with youths and your patterns will be too established to change. Woodbadge will have less effect. Besides at three years your kid is what 14-15? He is almost out and even less likely to change than you.
  21. I took it mid way through being a Bear den Leader. I think taking it as a Webelos 1 or 2 leader would be a very good time. It prepares you for what's ahead so when you get to a troop you have a good basis on how it should work. Of course if you have Woodbadge and go to a troop that has no Woodbadgers and is a bit anti-woodbadge, then you will have problems.
  22. Well I completed my second weekend of Powder Horn. As much as Woodbadge is all about leadership, Powder Horn is all about the outings. We learned where to take youths, what training we would need and where to go get it. Powder Horn is a course in youth vacation planning. There was a lesson on Venturing awards and how to work those into the program but as a Boy Scout leader I kind of glossed over that. The best parts were the discussions among the participants. All the "we went there" added up to a lot of information and informal training. For a Venture leader or a thinking about
  23. Since this thread started with liability can it end with a Dutch Oven recipe?
  24. I agree with Eagledad nearly all the problems of boys leaving a troop has to do with the troop and not what the boy did 1 - 2 years ago as webelos. Heck, the Boy Scout program is designed for kids to come in off the street and join. All those things you did as a webelos leader improved his retention in the troop. Thinking you should done this or held additional parent meetings during the year to help with the transition, I say, ttthhhpppptt! It would not have changed a thing. My own reflection: What I did right as a webelos leader: Camped. We did den camping as wolves. Yea there
  25. My experience is that Council will be the most forgiving of all levels of authority. If he is a good scoutmaster who shows remorse let it go. If miss busy body lady keeps pushing it will come down to either he or she goes. Give her a map and phone numbers to other local troops. Now if this were a couple venture crew kids, then this thread would make 8 pages in one day. And someone heads should roll!
×
×
  • Create New...