Jump to content

David CO

Members
  • Content Count

    2507
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    80

David CO last won the day on September 22

David CO had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

1342 Excellent

About David CO

  • Rank
    Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Illinois
  • Occupation
    middle school teacher
  • Interests
    Sports

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. My religion does not impose any rules about not having appropriate one-on-one interactions outside of church functions. Nor does it impose two-deep adult leadership outside of church. I don't know of any religion or organization, other than BSA, that does this. I do think BSA is unique in this regard. I could be wrong, but I don't know of any.
  2. This topic has been about interactions outside of scouting. I think you are making the same mistake as BSA when you confuse the two things. There is a big difference between regulating activities at a unit campout and trying to control people's interactions outside of scouting.
  3. Right. Stop there. There is no point in looking any further for exceptions or loopholes. Those are the rules. Trying to conscientiously follow the BSA rules is like trying to never squash an ant. You can never walk in the grass. You can never drive a car. You must always keep an eye on the sidewalk every step of the way. It may be theoretically possible to do it, but it will ruin your life. It will ruin your kid's life.
  4. Don't fall for it. The council doesn't have the authority. The council can't force a Chartered Organization to accept anyone in their unit. If the parent doesn't like your unit, invite them to go elsewhere.
  5. Yes. Really. No one-on-one contact. That is about as clear a line as can be drawn. Now, in order to more fully answer your question, I have to venture into the area of opinion, which you asked me not to do. BSA intentionally made YP rules knowing that the adult leaders could not and would not follow them. The rules were made to be broken. No scouters in their right minds would forbid their son from ever having his friends over to the house to play. Does it violate the YP rules? Yes. Do it anyway. Will BSA ever say it's ok for your son to have his friends over to the house? No. Do it any way. If you are a teacher (like me), it is necessary for you to have one-on-one contact with students. Can't be avoided. Will BSA ever say that it's ok? Nope. Do it any way. School classrooms don't have two deep leadership. Will BSA say it's ok? Nope. Do it any way. I think you should stop looking for BSA documentation and just use common sense. If BSA doesn't want you to use common sense, do it anyway.
  6. If you're not fishing for opinions, I think you already know the answer. The BSA rules are very clear and well documented.
  7. True. I disagree with those who say we are a systemically racist country, but I do think we have become a systemically elitist country. IMO, that's almost as bad.
  8. There is definitely a feeling of aristocracy amongst the crowd that sits on most of these boards. They feel entitled. I think this is part of the reason why the millennials don't like joining service clubs. They are more than willing to help out, for a good cause, but they aren't willing to put up with all of this elitism nonsense.
  9. Only for the sort of guy who thinks that profiteering off of kids is nice work.
  10. There is no published price, of course. I've been told the price for a seat on the board starts at around $10,000. I'm not sure if that is a one-time gift or an annual donation. Either way, it is way beyond my means.
  11. Only the wealthy volunteers.
  12. If that is the case, BSA should lose its tax exemption.
  13. Sorry. Any defense of national is too much.
  14. Very close. The early guys (including Boyce) had always intended for scouting to have a broad appeal that reached beyond social and economic classes. The charter reflects this attitude. The first scout executive (West) pulled off a palace coup, and drove out most of the organization's founders (including Boyce). He then transformed BSA into a money-making operation, eliminated the competition, and secured an astronomical salary for himself. This would make a great TV miniseries. I'm surprised it has never been done.
  15. This is the same argument that James West and William Boyce had 100 years ago. Boyce wanted to expand scouting to include working class boys. West wanted to build a program that would appeal more to middle-class and white-collar households. The executives have always wanted an elitist scouting program. That's where the $$$ is.
×
×
  • Create New...