Jump to content

mattsid

Members
  • Content Count

    5
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

1 Neutral

About mattsid

  • Rank
    Junior Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    San Jose CA

Recent Profile Visitors

168 profile views
  1. mattsid

    LDS leaving BSA?

    Hey gblotter, Yes, our Stake had our Troops, Crews and Teams all registered individually, luckily I didn't have to deal with the recharter headache but from what I heard it was a real pain. We had the same mass migration, my understanding is that the boys were co-registered sometime in August or early September in the Crew and in the Troop, they weren't sure at that time what they did with the leaders records but our advancement person was going to manual register us as ASMs during recharter to avoid any possible issues. Your experience with how the Crews and Teams ran is exactly as ours, we were really a Boy Scout Patrol running as a Venturing Crew, we did (do) high adventure activities, went camping, and generally caused trouble the only difference between us and our younger patrol was they focused more of their weekly activities on merit badges where we focused more on career building and skills. I have yet to see an LDS Varsity Crew implement the varsity program, I heard rumors of someone trying to do it once but I'm pretty sure it was an urban legend. Our Venturing program in all reality isn't really focused much on scouting at all, most of the boys, at least now, are either Eagles or have no interest in becoming eagles. They seem to focus mostly on career and skill building activities. I think what most people don't realize is that the actual change for most LDS unit's won't be that much different from what they are already doing. If a unit is strong in scouting they will continue to be strong in scouting because it's a way to fulfill the objectives of the Church for our Young Men. With the changes I think the Church has just given us more options to help fulfill that goal. If a unit hasn't been strong in Scouting it will hopefully give their leaders more options (insert my 2 cents and my unit on unit blood bath skills but if they couldn't pull off Scouting they probably won't be too good at pulling off the Church's activity program but what do I know...). It also stops us from having to register every boy who's on our records, for those of you who don't know the Church automatically registered every young man who was of scouting age into the scouting unit whether they had ever attend a meeting or not, whether they had interest or not, whether they had ever attended church or not. The biggest concern I have for the transition is for the units who either stop the scouting program all together for the older boys (which is not how I read the instructions from our leaders) or decided to pick and choose what they follow. Our unit has decided to follow the GTSS (that's the right acronym for Guide to Safe Scouting right ), I'm envisioning a lot of units picking and choosing, saying this is a scouting activity and this is a YM's activity thus trying to skirt the safety rules. I think that will open a lot of risk to the youth and a lot of liability for the church until they come out with some more detailed guidelines. (I will admit however that it would be nice to have some more freedom with shooting activities). Yep, I'm down here in the SVMBC, Quicksilver District. Not the most experienced Scouter in the world but trying to learn something new every day. -Matt
  2. mattsid

    LDS leaving BSA?

    As a leader of 14 and 15 year old boys in the LDS program I think there's a key item missing from the conversation. Like in the traditional scouting program some LDS units run good programs and some LDS units run poor programs, units that run good programs will continue to help their boys work in patrols and advance in the program, units that ran poor programs will unfortunately have boys who will suffer. In our unit (we call them Wards) I'm a Varsity Scout Coach for the next 23 days after that my responsibility for the boys and for their progress towards Eagle and learning important skills doesn't go away. On January 1st I change to a Assistant Scoutmaster (half of the training is already done, waiting for the next OLS class to open to finalize everything) and my boys will now work together in a patrol under the troop instead of in a Varsity Team. Will some Wards who have little interest in Scouting shut down after boys turn 14, unfortunately they probably will but I don't think these Wards are currently pushing scouting skills, they are just following along in the motions while not really offering much support along the way. -Matt
  3. mattsid

    More than Testing Scouting Skills

    Mark, I've been following along since a few days in, it's a great adventure and his blog is interesting to read. I'd recommend everyone follow along. --Matt
  4. mattsid

    Login Issues?

    I had the same issue this morning as well.-Matt
  5. mattsid

    Been Lurking For A While

    Hello fellow Scouters, I've been lurking around the forums for the past few months and decided to sign up this morning. I've been a Webelos Den Leader for the past two and a half years and have recently been called as a Varsity Coach (can you tell I'm from an LDS unit?). I'm looking forward to learning a ton from the forum, I've already found it a very interesting read. Y.I.S., Matt
×