Jump to content

mashmaster

Members
  • Content Count

    1588
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    27

Posts posted by mashmaster

  1.  

     

    I think this instance is exactly why Tiger Cubs have to have an adult partner. Older (neurotypical) children can handle themselves in the bathroom.

     

     

    Oi Vay, the other boy would need to take care of himself. The boys should be able to travel together with a buddy to the restroom. The parent can travel with his own son. I've always been wary of one adult with two boys anyway. I'm a YPT facilitator, unfortunately there are sick people out there, and boys make horrible witnesses. If a parent goes with multiple boys, grab another parent and have them walk with you. You will have a nice conversation and get to know them :-)

     

    I've had leaders accused before, and after the investigation they were cleared. Some parents like to interpret the rules. So it is best to have adults travel in pairs too. And yes, I wish it was different.

  2. I've been to Woodbadge, presented at UofS, and am on the Round table staff. Woodbadge is a totally different animal in my opinion from the others. The other too are much more practical for the units on short term goals and activities. Wood Badge tends to have a longer lifetime and effect but usually not as immediate of an impact.

     

    It seems pretty specific to me and heck, round tables are fun.

  3. I understand why they are doing this. As it stands now 5th grader joining the program has a huge mountain to climb to get AOL and crossover with his new friends. The other interesting thing I noticed is AOL requires a total of 7 adventures. If each one requires 2 den meetings and a field trip cross over is going to be pushed back a month or two or more for school based packs that don't work on advancement over the summer.

     

    IMHO, a scout joining in 5th grade shouldn;t earn his AOL. AOL is something on top of Webelos not separate. This separation is the biggest problem I have with the new system.

    • Downvote 1
  4. It looks potentially doable. I'll have to be rigorous on having people trained and controlled on following the rules. Sounds like non-swimmers are not feasable in the surf though. So they will have to dig sand castles.

  5. Our pack was looking at potential campouts for next year and someone came up with the idea to tent camp at a campground at a beach not far from us. We have the opportunity to have a marine biologist run a great program for the boys.

     

    My question is about camping at the campground at the beach. It has all the necessary facilities for council to approve it, but I don't see anything in the guide to safe scouting about whether we can do it or not. I understand the boys can't go swimming in the water, but is it just best to stay away because the boys will be drawn to the water?

  6. I have taken powder horn.....It was little more than how to backpack, they brought in the local outdoor shop owner to talk about gear.

     

    It was winter, so we kayaked in an indoor pool same pool snokeled.

     

     

    The entire course could have been handled by a 4 page booklet with a list of resources.

     

    totally different from the Powder Horn training that I am signed up for in the fall. It is held at large council campground and has hands on experience in way more activities that you described. Sounds like they don't have a good standard for the course.

  7. On a campout we had 2 weeks ago, our boys in our unit got the opportunity to meet Major General Webb. It was really interesting hearing him tell the boys about how he was a cub scout and boy scout. He told them he only made it to Life scout, and still regrets not making Eagle. Was interesting to hear that from someone as accomplished as him to have that regret.

     

    Experiences like that are something that are unique to scouts IMHO. what a life experience.

    • Upvote 1
  8. Hi Folks:

     

    I have a bit different perspective about what TL is about, and why I am attracted to it. Morally straight behavior is not only about physical intimacy. It is about how people treat each other, and requires a common standard that everyone agrees on.

     

    I have recently gone through a problem with our BSA Unit caused by very different moral standards. That is something I expect can be better resolved in TL. When (not if) there are problems we can go to the bible with the required Chaplain and work it out - biblically.

     

    Something that I see lacking in this thread is how much the Adult Leaders truly make any youth program fruitful. It is not what is in some book, it is how the program is presented. I want a Christian based program for my boy and the other boys. I really think there is a difference. And it need not be "churchy". Scripture is full of matter-of-fact common sense.

     

     

    work it out biblically? If that was as easy as you make it sound there wouldn't be so many versions of Christianity. The bible is interpreted by man. So which is correct? For instance, the Christian church I attend says that homosexuality is OK according to the Bible. I know that is not the majority interpretation of the Bible but it is an interprettation from a Christian faith including many "educated religious leaders". I think the ten commandments, might be the only non-interprettable part of the bible.

     

    I have nothing against TL, and I wish the members well. I just think that they will have many of the same problems over time.

  9. Talked with my course director and we are going to do it at our next pack meeting. He said it is a quick 5 minutes, and our cubmaster wants to do it there since it is my final meeting as me as committee chair. I started the pack 3 years ago and it is time to pass the torch.

×
×
  • Create New...