clbkbx
Members-
Content Count
102 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Articles
Store
Everything posted by clbkbx
-
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
That is how the Settlement Trust Contribution payout timeline is determined. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
There is a Settlement Trust Contribution from BSA that includes a note, cash, artwork, oil & gas leases, etc. (+/- $250 million is the most recent estimate I can find... not sure if that has been updated). After that is paid there is a Settlement Growth Payment (see #267 in the most recent plan), which I believe is what you are referencing. Up to $100 million additional based on membership rates above 1.5 million scouters or 0.5 million volunteers. The $100 million would be realized if they have 5.5% annual growth. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
This is just what I wanted to know… is there a normal ratio of expenses to settlement amount? From what I’ve read and this discussion, it seems to vary quite a bit. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
What’s a few zeros at this point?! You are, of course correct. It was something around $500 million. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
Hi @fred8033... to the first question, I only know that's broken down in the filings including the by-firm table that was posted above which gives a good overall sense. I thought that in your initial post you were saying something along the lines of: an entity pays X fees to get to Y settlement (basically, what is BSA going to pay out of pocket to get through bankruptcy) and that X is normally 25-30% of Y. It seems like I might have been mistaken. For the second part, I think we are saying the same thing. The BSA is putting a certain amount ($500k iirc) into the Trust regardless of -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
Thanks @fred8033. I didn't think the bottom two should be included when weighing the typical range but, like I said, I haven't been able to find any good reference for that. Administration is estimated around 10% and lawyer contingency fees are typically around 30% so right away you're at 40% not being paid out to survivors (assuming most are being represented by counsel). The BSA costs always seem to me to be about it's continued viability. They're not adding or subtracting to the amount they put into the Trust based on what it takes to get through bankruptcy. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
I've often wondered this (what is a typical fee to settlement ratio) and never found a good source. If the above is normal, wouldn't the fees in this case be about 50% less than normal? $2.7B x 0.25 = $675MM and $2.7B x 0.3 = $810MM. Currently at $368MM. (BTW, I'm not a lawyer!) -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
Revised plan filed. Redline here: https://casedocs.omniagentsolutions.com/cmsvol2/pub_47373/7f73fba1-1980-4766-a6b3-d80e203fd73f_10263.pdf -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
Thanks. Two comments on the article. 1. I thought the case was going to be appealed. This article says it’s uncertain. I wonder if that’s just because of where the case is or if it not being appealed is a possible outcome. 2. One of the interviewees said “For some victims it’s a great result,” which is something I haven’t heard from anyone. Is there a scenario where someone is getting a great outcome? -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
The TCC today posted a "preliminary statement" at tccbsa.com. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
I was wrong about this. The most recent version includes related entities. -
Chapter 11 announced - Part 11 - Judge's Opinion
clbkbx replied to Eagle1993's topic in Issues & Politics
I'm going to look at this again, but fairly certain the Bates report is only appropriate for a BSA-only approach. Basically, they said the historical settlement amounts were allocated as percentages to BSA National, LC's, CO's and others. Then they took the BSA National portion as the basis. But the LC's and CO's are being released. -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
I think if you check out Moral Panic: Changing Concepts of the Child Molester in Modern America by Philip Jenkins and some information from Stephen Robertson (Crimes Against Children is the book but some of that research is incorporated here if you have a library card: https://www.jstor.org/stable/40663407) you will see that there was a period, defined by Jenkins as the "Liberal Era" from 1958-1976, when what you are describing was the norm. It has changed over time more than you might expect including how it was prosecuted/charged (even as it's been a crime right since the founding of the var -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
Not sure you could find worse examples for a CSA forum. -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
I know there are many different outcomes. My abuse was in the 90’s and he was arrested while still the SM. I guess I didn’t make an “official report” but as noted, not a word to me or my family. To other abuse victims (or those that would have knowledge): did BSA provide any counseling to you or to your knowledge? I guess to @elitts’s point, for instances after the 80’s. -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
I hear you on this. Sunlight is the best disinfectant, thank you for sharing some of your story. Every victim’s experience is difficult to read. If it’s not too burdensome to facilitate this conversation, I find your perspective is very valuable. -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
As I noted above, no one in BSA ever reached out to me. Here’s some more context: it was the late 1990’s (hope that doesn’t get counted as “old timer”!), my abuser was arrested (bc my family and I reported it to the police) so it was publicly known, I was in Scouts from Tiger through 18 yrs old, Eagle/Vigil/youth leadership positions so I knew/interacted with a lot of adults (SE on down). I never heard they did any reimbursement until recently (my broke college self could have used it more than now). That said, I’ve been considering it for my more recent during-bankruptcy therapy but -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
Sure, individual outcomes vary. That’s a lot different than, for example, what @johnsch322 noted about different outcomes based on reporting. National BSA was the correct entity to be aggregating (which they did) and analyzing (which it sure seems they didn’t) this information. I’ve made this comment before: that the last vote mainly changed YPT is outrageous. (I do hope the Neutral path helps some victims.) It shows me that BSA… having entered bankruptcy to address their past failures around CSA… are still prioritizing their org instead of youth. It’s embarrassing. The TCC -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
That is very interesting, thanks. I thought that the IV files would be released and there would be more in-depth study but now understand that’s not likely (noting that it seems to make sense why they won’t be fully released). BSA let someone fully review them but I didn’t think the analysis was unbiased. If we know this type of abuse is on-going, there are probably other insights to minimize it (a la your example of reporting to authorities not the org, which does seem to be the better approach and I understand is current practice in BSA). -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
For sure and I agree we need to keep evolving. I think there’s a difference between the norms you mention and CSA. I’m younger than you but am fairly certain male-male pedophilia was not accepted as part of society. So the everyone-was-covering-up-crimes so it’s fine approach always seems a bit gross to me. Police covering up racial violence at the time thought the violence was ok. What were organizations covering up CSA doing other than protecting their reputation? -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
Same here within the troop but, as noted, I do believe there was at least one victim before me. My troop was not listed in released IV files. I reached out to a family acquaintance younger than me that was in the same troop and he said there were rumors of someone else after me. I wish that I hadn’t asked… it’s one more thing that I don’t know from a time that I’m still processing. (Thanks again to this forum… and therapists!) -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
That's right, no one talked to me, either. This was in the early/mid 90's. As far as I know now, my abuser was not in the IV files although I'm fairly certain I was not the only one. I wonder how it will change my perception if I do find out as part of this process that he was. Reading your post about (at least) 11 other suspected victims has hit hard. I'm so sorry, it's hard to fathom. -
BSA CSA: Concealment or Trustworthy, Loyal...?
clbkbx replied to ThenNow's topic in Issues & Politics
As I understand it now, an ASM reached out to the SE, concerned that I was being abused. The ASM was told everything was ok (not sure on what basis). I know my parents weren’t contacted because they were/are upset when they found this out. -
My best guess analysis linked above. There was a data set after the last vote which included the alleged abuse (so a tier could be determined) and alleged location (so SOL's could be factored in). I'm confident that it's less than fully funded. The rough estimate I made was that it is in the neighborhood of 30% funded (as compared to liabilities) with no additional contributions. As @MYCVAStory noted in a response, there are known changes (my estimate: 10% to administer the fund) and suspected changes (how many people will follow through, fraud, etc.). Re: how many claims will be paid, t