I figured this might be a good place to begin. After reading through the requirements (see below for all requirements), it seems that they haven't exactly put enough thought into the impact on scouts and advancement. I have no problem with any of the requirements (in fact, overall I feel it's probably insufficient and too easy, IMHO) except #4. Teaching to your troop via the EDGE method seems fine for small groups, but when you give a total of 4 possible exercises and we have a group of 30+ scouts from 6th-8th grade, it sorta makes it difficult to teach. The best solution I can see is to break