I can't believe that anyone would discourage the BSA from conducting backgroud checks. I am the chief investigtor for a sheriffs department and work child victimization crimes. It is a fact that child predators will seek out any means necessary to gain access to children. Who thinks that the Boy Scouts are excluded?
I am not sure that a private company would best serve the needs of the BSA, but when you look at a national orginization this might work better. Individual states have various requirements to conduct criminal records checks. So it might be easier for a national based company to do it.
I salute the BSA for what they are doing. I also do not think that the BSA is moving to the right. One comment that was made earlier about the "Twilight Zone Troop" was right on. I am an eagle scout and now have two sons in scouting and I have never seen any such thing and if I ever do, I will find another troop.