Jump to content

JFL49

Members
  • Content Count

    99
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by JFL49

  1. "You basically reveal stuff about your personal life like who your best friend is. I actually don't remember much of it other than "I don't want to be here doing this."

     

    This is a description of the "Who Me" game (after dinner on Day 1), and not The Game of Life.

     

    Having staffed a number of courses and been the Scoutmaster for one course, the "magic" about the Game of Life is its position in the syllabus - at the end of Day 2 when there has been lots of competition already and people are tired. While the game is valuable, the debriefing is vitally important patch up bad feelings and bring everyone back to the real world. It is a difficult game to facilitate CORRECTLY, and only very experienced Scouters should be selected for the position, since the game can get out of hand with an inexperienced leader. I added a Scoutmaster Minute after the debriefing, to make sure the participants heard a second voice about the real lessons learned from the Game.

     

    Horror stories are often the result of inexperienced facilitators.

     

    And then I know of at least one Council that runs the game as the last event on Day 3 before everyone returns home, to ensure that people leave weekend one angry and frustrated. That Council makes sure participants are Storming between weekends one and two. BTW, this approach is a horrible idea.

  2. A careful reading of the guidelines for the District Nominating Committee shows that only voting members present at the Annual Business Meeting may vote. There appears to be no provision for proxy voting.

     

    Also, the District Commissioner is technically recommended for the position by the District Nominating Committee. It is up to the Council Executive Board to approve (or reject) the District candidate for the Commissioner position, with the concurrence of the Council Scout Executive. However, from a practical standpoint, the Council Commissioner can (and often does) have a major role in selecting District Commissioners.

     

    http://www.scouting.org/filestore/commissioner/pdf/513-332_Fillable.pdf

     

     

  3. I use two versions of a the beading ceremony: a short version and a long version. The short version runs about 9 minutes and the long version about 11 minutes. It may run one or two minutes longer if there are multiple Scouters being recognized. If there are a good number Wood Badgers present, we'll sing the entire Gilwell song. Otherwise, we'll just sing the verses corresponding to the recipient's critters.

     

    It is disrespectful to take up any more of the audience's time, whether it be a Camporee, Blue and Gold, Roundtable, or even our annual Council Wood Badge Dinner. Also, run a long beading ceremony at ANY event and you can be guaranteed that you'll never be invited back to that unit or District. Never.

  4. Our troop routinely schedules 3 Courts of Honor per year, in the fall, winter, and spring. Any and all rank advancements are presented.

     

    If an Eagle family wants to hold an ECOH on their own (most do), they organize and pay for it. They invite the rest of the troop (if they want to)

  5. I'm not sure what the phrase "acting as the Scoutmaster" means. Either you are the Scoutmaster or you're not.

     

    But I digress.

     

    As Scoutmaster, I gave each Eagle Scout a well thought out letter of congratulations for his "memory book". Words of wisdom he can look back on in 5 or 10 or 25 years. Additionally, our Troop would give each Eagle Scout a lifetime membership in NESA, because we thought that was important.

  6. I've had the honor of chairing both the DAM and SB Committees. There is absolutely no discussion of monetary issues for either award. Zero. At the Council level, the SB Committee has two representatives from each District and two from the Board. Once in a blue moon the SB Committee receives an application for someone who appeared to be a large contributor. However, unless the person was known to a majority of representatives from the Districts (through their good work for Scouting), they don't have a chance of being recognized with the SB award.

  7. The game went pretty well on our course last August/September. After the debriefing, I gave a Scoutmaster minute about the importance of being able to Trust our Leaders. It felt like the combination of the debriefing plus the SM Minute got the important points across.

     

    The syllabus is silent on a SM Minute after the game. I obviously thought it was important enough to have one. I'd recommend all courses do that.

  8. Eamonn,

     

    The WB Administrative Guide actually says the opposite.

     

    Paraphrasing: During Days 1 thru 5, staff members will wear a Troop 1 neckerchief held in place with a participants woggle and Wood Badge beads. On Day 6, staff members will wear the official Wood Badge neckerchief, woggle, and beads.

     

    According to the insignia guide, Wood Badge beads can be worn by adult Sea Scouters

     

    http://www.scouting.org/scoutsource/Media/InsigniaGuide/09.aspx

     

    However, I have been told the "tradition" is that Sea Scouters in uniform do not wear Wood Badge beads, apparently for safety reasons (the leather thong could get caught on something on board ship and injure the wearer). The same tradition seems not to apply to Sea Scouts and Scouters wearing a bonsun's pipe on a lanyard.

  9. I recently ordered one from National Supply using this form:

     

    http://www.scoutstuff.org/media/content/docs/pdfs/Flag_Order_Form.pdf

     

    Customer service was helpful and the flag arrived in about 4 weeks. I believe if you order the flag through your local Scout Shop, you do not pay for shipping (but I could be mistaken).

     

    Don't forget to order the flag pole and flag topper (if you need them). Same for the flag stand. Also - flag storage bag.

  10. As with many "things" Scouting, oh how I wish that guidance from National was better written. The phrase "as indicated" clouds the issue, IMHO.

     

    Since I also chair my Council's Wood Badge Committee, I will go with our Council's approach (and traditions): your Wood Badge beads may be worn with any neckerchief or with no neckerchief, as long as you are wearing your field uniform.

     

    Personally, the only neckerchief that I wear my beads with is the Gilwell (taupe/dove grey/pink) neckerchief.

  11. This link refers to the woggle and other parts of the regalia:

     

    http://www.scouting.org/scoutsource/Media/InsigniaGuide/06I.aspx

     

    Parsing the language in the link, and using the "rules" that our Council goes by: your Wood Badge beads may be worn with any neckerchief or with no neckerchief, as long as you are wearing your field uniform ("Class A" uniform in the military parlance).

     

    The woggle may only be worn with the Wood Badge neckerchief. And you if you wear your Wood Badge neckerchief, you MUST also wear your woggle and your beads.

     

    BTW: "Wood Badge" is always two words.

     

  12. "The course syllabus clearly allows for the facilitator to introduce "breaks" or conferences as needed between rounds, typically one or two conferences. The conferences are optional. The facilitator has to judge the benefit of these conferences versus lessons being learned. "

     

    I'm extracting this info from the syllabus.

  13. Perhaps Pogo (or Walt Kelly) said it best: We have met the enemy and he is us.

     

    Our units are the Council. Everyone at this Roundtable is a member of the Council. Frequent cynicisms aside, the Council is designed to exist for the benefit of the units. If we dont raise money for the Council, who will? Raising money for the Council, whether it be through FOS, popcorn, ad sales, recognition luncheons, whatever, means we are raising money for us.

  14. I guess one point to make is that popcorn sales programs are developed by the Council to raise funds for the unit AND for the Council. Its up to each Council what the split is, but in many cases, the split is 50:50 between unit and Council. If you use the Trails End model, 30% goes to Trails End for product (and their profit) and 70% goes to Scouting. Certainly, trash bags, fertilizer, Christmas trees, first aid kits, and the like are great unit fundraisers, and may keep the cost of summer camp down FOR THE UNIT. But those fundraisers dont keep the cost of summer camp down for the Councils side of the ledger. Low popcorn sales results hurts the Council, and places a greater burden on the units for other fundraising ventures such as FOS.

  15. My advice: step away from the Troop for 6 12 months. Im sure your OA Chapter could use your help, or your District Committee, or become a Unit Commissioner (but not for your Troop). Or become an ASM in another Troop. Let your Troop work through it troubles.

     

    The world will look much different in the fall or next spring.

     

×
×
  • Create New...