We can file under "may not see it in my tenure" but let's lay some groundwork:
IT through scouting.org just needs to improve even to manage what it does now, but let's suppose it gets better (and this would have have to be on the par of Google campus better) and can reliably track each user's scouting career ...
Once a scout, always a scout. Opinions from old and young alike matter. So ...
Votes are proportional to service stars (years registered in the program).
For issues specific to the program, votes are proportional to time served in that program.
Current vs. lapsed vs. never r