bsaz

I don't believe alternative requirements for second class are available if the scout's phobia doesn't result from a permanent mental or physical disability. Seems like this case is a phobia that possibly could be overcome by sensitivity training with a therapist or psychologist. Since scouting basically adopts disability definitions under the ADA, you need to look to the ADA definitions. If the phobia results from a permanent mental or physical disability (and a doctor certifies it), the scout might have a chance with the council advancement committee. But it doesn't sound likely based on f