Jump to content

gaucho

Members
  • Content Count

    38
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by gaucho

  1. If it comes down to wearing only only 1 patch, think of it this way. BSA's org chart is upside down, meaning youth are at the top. Then direct contact leaders, then Unit support leaders (i.e. committee), then district and council leaders are low on that org chart. Unit leader position is more important than a District Commissioner. So I would wear your unit leader position over commissioner patch.

  2. Not sure if that is really needed. After the arrowhead honor, we have the commissioner's key knot, Distinguished Commissioner's award knot and the commissioner's college knot. Granted 1 takes 3 years to earn and the other two over 5 years but still. Most commissioner's probably don't feel the need for any more. I am interested to see the criteria.

  3. In the insignia guide, it shows specifically how to place the patches for non-unit scouters without the pocket and it is the old way.

     

    Personally, I like the idea of the arrowhead honor being in the place of the unit numerals and would make sense to keep it that way even without the pocket on the sleeve. But per the guide, the arrowhead goes below position patch if there is no pocket on sleeve.

  4. eolesen:

     

    True women leaders do not camp out with LDS troops, but there are many women leaders who are assistant scoutmasters in LDS troops working with the 11 year old patrol. Also, there are many Scoutmasters of LDS troops who are not LDS at all. They do need to agree to uphold to certain standards of substance use, etc.

     

    Just wanting to clarify. But CO's have control over their units in a lot of respects. Venturing can have co-ed units, but they can also be all male and even all female crews. Haven't seen an all female crew, but that would be cool if a CO felt that need for that.

  5. Yep, we are and the boys love it. Best week out there for an individual camp. They run NYLT for the older boys, but the Brownsea 22 course is for the younger scouts here.

  6. Absolutely!!! Bottom of Page 5 2009-2010 Insignia guide: "Neckerchief slides. Several official slides are available from the Supply Group. Boy-made handicraft slides also may be worn."

  7. There is nothing in the insignia guide that states when a medal should or should not be worn. They can be worn ANYTIME. If an eagle wants to wear his eagle medal, more power to him at anytime in my opinion and is always appropriate.

     

    In general knots are for informal wear. The insignia guide states "Cloth badges and embroidered square knots are representative of metal pin-on awards are are designed for the convenience of the wearer. Generally, when a cloth badge is worn, the metal one is not worn." So there is no hard rule about when to wear either and that the knots are for CONVENIENCE.(This message has been edited by gaucho)

  8. Thanks for the replies! Knowing the two individuals I saw using those flags, I think they do it in honor of the military, not to be like the military. Especially since I know at least one is a veteran, probably both.

     

    This issue seems to have heated some people up. We need to remember that right or wrong when judgments are thrown out on their motives, we have no idea. I was just asking if was proper or not, or if there is anything specifying that only the BSA issued uniform patch was the one to be used. How often are we offended when in actuality the offender had no intention to hurt. With all of the service these two put in helping kids, I don't think it is for machismo they use the military style flag. I think they needed to put a new one on to replace the faulty flag and chose that style. But I don't know, just wanted to know the facts.

     

    Thanks again to all that chimed in.

  9. I saw two scouters (one a Dist. Commissioner) with their new uniforms. They had replaced the flag (they applied the new one right over the old one) with an Army style (Stars on the right). The old ones were already coming off they said. I personally really liked it, but is there anything against using one of those?

×
×
  • Create New...