EarthMan

Thanks to everyone for contributing to this discussion. Here is what I would write for an FAQ from what I know now (obviously reflecting my biases): Q. Are sheath knives permitted in scouting? A. Sheath knives are not banned by any official BSA publication. The Guide to Safe Scouting does say "Avoid large sheath knives. They are heavy and awkward to carry, and unnecessary for most camp chores except for cleaning fish." Most people agree that large sheath knives are not appropriate for most tasks you are likely to perform while scouting. However smaller sheath knives (with bla

Will some of the opponents of sheath knives please explain why they are considered less safe than folding knives? Because sheath knives seem much safer too me. A good sheath knife is made of one solid piece of steel going the full length of the handle, so it is much sturdier for doing real work and less likely to break. It doesn't have to fit inside a handle so the steel can be thicker. It is simpler because it has no moving parts. It won't fold up on you accidently when using it or sharpening it. There is no potential for injury when closing it. Some locking knives have a complicat