Discipline Adults or Boys

[Tampa Turtle 1011]

Here is the situation:

 

During a meeting an unknown boy sneaks into the hut and defaces another Patrol's Patrol Box.

 

Who should discipline the boy(s) the SM or the SPL/PLC?

[Eagle732 27]

SPL/PLC with SM consent (so things don't get too crazy)

This is just my opinion

[Tampa Turtle 1011]

That is what I suggested.

[fred8033 1593]

What level of defacing? Using a knife to cut words into it? Permanent marker? Ketchup? Other?

[Beavah 205]

Execution by firing squad staffed by da patrol whose box was defaced. Usin' paintballs of course.

 

B

 

[Tampa Turtle 1011]

(Mind you I have only seen photoss)

 

Mostly paint. No words. But it was the most lovingly cared for Patrol box.

[dennis99ss 10]

When things go viral....one little things builds into another, and builds into another, and builds into another, each increasing in severity, because the boys seem to build upon the bad things that happen, have a troop meeting, by the SM, assisted by the SPL, to "lay down the law" and set things straight. It can be used as a teaching moment as well.

 

On one off things, see if the SPL can handle it, with some advise if necessary.

 

[raisinemright 13]

Sounds like the proper path is for the SPL to hand the lad a brand new pack of sandpaper

[Eagledad 2779]

>>Who should discipline the boy(s) the SM or the SPL/PLC?

[Twocubdad 665]

Since "discipline" is the training necessary to prevent future bad behavior, I would say that training should be led by the Scouts (with the usual supervision and coaching from the adults). If they're looking for ideas for what that training should be, I'd suggest the entire troop learn what it takes to clean up such vandalism and perhaps some additional practice in how to clean anything else which needs it.

 

Of course if you really mean "punishment" that's a different deal, especially since the perps are unknown. If they were known, punishment would be up to their parents, not the troop and certainly not the youth. The troop adult leadership may decide that since the perps are unable to behave as Scouts they should take a break from being Scouts for a time. I also think making amends for their wrong doing requires making things right with the patrol whose gear was damaged.

 

 

[Tokala 16]

Since I just renewed my youth protection training...

 

It states that only adults are to discpline Scouts.

[dg98adams 18]

I read over this post and decided to post my opinion.

 

Discipline?

 

There's 2 choices:

 

If someone saw him do it and he admits guilt.

 

#1 - Send him home for a month of meetings.... or

#2 - Hand him sand paper/paint to make it right.

 

His choice

 

If no one saw him actually do it, and NO ONE ELSE admits guilt.

 

Hand every Scout, other than the Patrol whose box it is,

sand paper/paint for some cheerful service.

[BDPT00 41]

I think it's a non-issue ... nobody was hurt or humiliated. It was an innocent prank, and should be encouraged (depending upon which units condone that kind of thing, of course). It will happen in real life, and the offended patrol needs to man-up. It's a growth experience, and now they can do it to the next patrol (the Snipes!). Sounds like a fun tradition, and it originated with the boys. Leave it alone, and see where it goes.

BDPT00

[bacchus 10]

What Tokala said. Only adults are to discipline the scouts. Otherwise I believe they call it hazing.

[Tampa Turtle 1011]

BDP...yes paint wars. Could be interesting. Perhaps the offending party will have to sing for his punishment.