Jump to content

Bird Study MB and Climate Change and Outdoor Code


Recommended Posts

On 2/1/2022 at 9:56 PM, RememberSchiff said:

What struck me in the article was the sentence " build a shower building/storm shelter (tornado) which will house up to 200 people at a cost of $250,000."  which IMHO seemed an under estimate.

I found "pictures of what the proposed building will resemble.  These are not actual photos, just a representation of the proposed building" at Prairielands Council website

https://prairielandsbsa.org/pages/camp-drake-selective-timber-harvest

Prairielands Council (well the SE at least) viewpoint

I did not find a forestry management plan there, just general statements:

This harvest should take place between late 2021 through Winter of 2022.  Pike Lumber Company from Indiana will be doing the work.  The supervisor for our project, Dane Larsen is a Forester who has extensive experience in both timber harvests and forestry. They are also familiar with all the requisite Illinois State laws...There has been much speculation about how Camp will look after the harvest.  Please keep in mind, this isn’t a clear cutting of Camp Drake.  1,400 trees will be impacted, which represents roughly 1% of the trees in our 160 acres of woodlands at Camp Robert Drake.  Parts of Camp Drake will certainly look different, but the company involved has committed to leaving the camp better than it was!

Eagle Scout Joel Armas opinion on Council logging plan

Recently, the local Prairielands Council decided to liquidate all trees in the forested areas of Camp. The contract was a no-bid open contract with one lumber company, Pike Lumber of Indiana. The plan calls for the aggressive removal of any commercially viable trees within Camp Drake, including trees in programming and camp sites. Over 1400 trees will be removed over the entire 160 acres of the wooded forest area within Camp Drake. The Camp Drake Forest is a legacy given to the current Council leadership by 90 years of Scout Executives, Executive Committees, Executive Boards and Camp Directors who chose to preserve the natural resources of Drake for future generations of scouts to benefit and enjoy.

The Prairielands Executive Committee has refused to allow anyone, including members of the Executive Board that have directly asked, to see a copy of the contract or any documentation executed by the Executive Committee. The Prairielands Council Executive Committee did not at any time solicit the input or involvement of the standing Prairielands Conservation Committee or the Prairielands Camping Committee. The Conservation Committee has formally asked for involvement in the planning and execution of the timber sale and has been formally rejected. Prairielands Executive Committee has failed to adequately communicate the specifics of the sale, which impact future camping plans and the unit’s financial deposits, to the units within Prairielands.

A standard competitive bid process was not followed....

More at source link:

https://www.smilepolitely.com/opinion/stop_the_logging_of_camp_drake_woodland/

Petition mentioned in News Gazette article

 Stop the Logging of Drake Woodland

Camp Robert Drake, located just south of Oakwood Illinois on the banks of the Salt Fork River, has just approved a plan to log 1400 trees. Camp Drake is located at the site of a former coal mine. The coal company who had cut the trees, drove deep cuts into the land, and ran away was forced to return and clean the remaining coal ash left behind by the mining, allowing the ecosystem to rebound and host a beautiful mature walnut, oak, and hickory forest. This logging would increase erosion, and cause more nutrients to enter the Salt Fork River. The Salt Fork is National Wild and Scenic River, and one of the cleanest in Illinois. This would cause an increase in algal blooms, as well as harming fish populations. Additionally the removal of mature trees will create a heightened risk of land falls at Camp Drake, which has steep ravines (scars from the mining done one hundred years ago).

Scouting has been under much scrutiny for its role in the abuse of many people by leaders and fellow scouts, leading to lawsuits by survivors of abuse. The need to raise money for survivors' settlements prompted Prairieland Council to embark on a logging campaign. To atone for the abuse of former scouts, the council has decided to place scars upon the land which will take hundreds of years to heal.

https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/stop-the-logging-of-drake-woodland

Maybe all moot, as the News Gazette article states:

"It appears to be too late. Logging, which began in early January, is about halfway finished."

 

 

Sounds like they have a forester involved.  That generally means a forestry plan exists, otherwise, why have a professional?  It's a bit like hiring an engineer to build a house and believe that there are no plans.  Unless the council bylaws indicate a bid process is required, I don't see that as a legitimate gripe.  However, that does bring into question the argument against logging.  Would the complainers be ok is there was a bidding process?  Joel Armas seems to be a little over emotional.  I also wouldn't call the harvesting of 9 trees per acre as a liquidation of the forested areas.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 47
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

I don't want to hijack the thread, and maybe this discussion about the Outdoor Code belongs in a separate thread. Our troop recites the Outdoor Code only rarely, but when they do they keep their

Years ago one of my scouts, in uniform, was at a restaurant with his father before our meeting. An elderly gentleman as he was leaving said "If you can recite the Outdoor Code, I will pay for your din

One of rarest eagles in world, a Steller's sea eagle, has been spotted in Maine this week. Maybe scouts can help track locations of this vagrant.   Doug Hitchox, a naturalist with

Posted Images

I have been unable to find the name of the forester or a documented harvest/replanting plan or even a tree survey.

Depends on the forest. If a forester cut nine of the most marketable (lumber $$$) trees on my one acre. I would likely lose 3 mighty oaks and six very tall eastern white pines ...goodbye windbreak and a large amount of shade.  Dead and diseased trees would only be cut for access and removing timber.

IMHO, if council leadership needs a bylaw to follow common business practice for bidding on projects, time for new leaders.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...

Here's an interesting mash-up of bird study and citizenship in society:

https://www.alleghenyfront.org/how-the-birding-community-is-working-for-racial-and-environmental-justice/

Quote
Tykee JamesCourtesy of Tykee James

HOW THE BIRDING COMMUNITY IS WORKING FOR RACIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE

JOHN WEBERMARCH 18, 2022
This story comes from our partners at WPSU.

Tykee James is a podcaster, community organizer, conservationist and environmental educator.

His love of birds led him to the National Audubon Society, where he is the government affairs coordinator in Washington, D.C. which involves lobbying for birds and taking congressional members on educational bird walks.

He was also the co-organizer of the first Black Birders Week and continues to advocate for more accessible and equitable outdoor spaces.

John Weber of WPSU’s “Take Note” program talked Tykee James. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...