New forum on how best to start a girls' troop?

[Treflienne 270]

How about adding a forum (or a subforum under Open Discussion - Program) with a name something like:

"Starting a new Scouts BSA girls' troop - practical how-to's"

This would be a place to how to best get the girls' troops started, and how to have the best possible experience for the girls AND for the boys in the troops to which they are linked,  not a place to rehash whether they should be started.

 

Edited November 27, 2018 by Treflienne
misplaced apostrophe

[karunamom3 28]

Good idea

 

[Treflienne 270]

Lots of dissusions currently on the practicalities of starting Linked/Girls Troops.   Seems like time for its own forum or subforum.  How about it @John-in-KC ?

[Cburkhardt 382]

I agree you need a specific forum ASAP on this.  It needs to be carefully monitored to focus on best practices.  Political commentary and obstructing negative comments need to be diverted.  

[qwazse 4342]

Well, if ASAP is what you need. You could create tags for your topics. Say, "Start-up", "Scouts BSA", "Girls", and "Troop".

File under open program, council relations, or whatever.

Most of what you all have discussed so far applies to boys' troops too.

The reason why I suggest this is that somewhere there is a venturing forum that us crew advisors rarely use. Why? Because most of what we really need to know is on the other forums. I mean, venturing is special, but not that special.

[shortridge 184]

FYI, there is a lot of practical advice being shared in two private Facebook groups:

- Scouts BSA Female Troops Volunteers is more free-form and loose. Lots of entry-level questions plus experienced information-sharing.

- BSA Family Packs / Girl Troops includes some National staff members, covers Cubs, and is stricter - posts require approval and admins have a heavier hand in closing threads that get off topic.

[Cburkhardt 382]

We are a best-practices all-girl Troop with 24 kids and 15 adults, so we do not need the help ourselves.  Since best practices are being handled elsewhere, I will cease my postings.

[mrkstvns 486]

4 hours ago, shortridge said:

FYI, there is a lot of practical advice being shared in two private Facebook groups:

- Scouts BSA Female Troops Volunteers is more free-form and loose. Lots of entry-level questions plus experienced information-sharing.

- BSA Family Packs / Girl Troops includes some National staff members, covers Cubs, and is stricter - posts require approval and admins have a heavier hand in closing threads that get off topic.

Yes, and by using Facebook you ALSO get the bonus benefits of...

• Being profiled by FB's data harvesting algorithms so as much personal data as cyberly possible can be gathered about you
• Having your device privacy settings, internet privacy settings, and even Facebook's own data privacy settings absolutely ignored when it suits Facebook's purposes
• Having all your personal data sold to marketers, Cambridge Analytics, and Russian spies seeking to manipulate you for political purposes
• Having your user credentials stolen so that hackers can not only get into your Facebook account, but also into EVERY web site that uses a federated authentication process (i.e., all those sites that "conveniently" tell you you can log in with your Facebook ID)
• Having your kids exposed to unethical (and illegal in many jurisdictions) smart phone apps designed to profile them for purposes of marketing and political division
• And many, MANY more risks that are swept under the rug by 99% of Americans who would rather share funny cat memes than think about their family's privacy

 

BTW: If you're going to reply to this, please take a few minutes to educate yourself about the facts of Facebook's MYRIAD privacy breaches from at least the past 12 months. If you don't know about any point I've briefly touched on, at least read the barest tip of the iceberg, here:  https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/18/technology/facebook-privacy.html