Jump to content

OFFICIAL NEWS RELEASE: Girls as Youth Members, All Programs


Recommended Posts

Actually have folk in my district who believe that the 11-17 year old program will have a new role for parents and younger siblings because the BSA keeps using "Family." They think it will be a continuation of Cub Scouts.

Well, there you go. National thought they were being clever, but they outsmarted themselves.

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 897
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

I'm glad the board made this decision. It is the right one, for our youth and for the future of Scouting. If some COs and leaders can't adjust to modern life, so be it. The Scouts will be just fine, r

I became Eagle shortly after you (1978).  When I joined, the old requirements were still in place, and I earned Second Class under them.  I had about half the requirements for First Class done when th

^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Nope, this argument is the straw man. Boy Scouts is for boys. So a member of an organization for boys -- that has been for boys only for over 100 years -- has a very valid argument aski

Well, there you go. National thought they were being clever, but they outsmarted themselves.

 

Additionally, some of the same folks thinks that since Cub Scout family camping has no requirements on the genders of the adults attending, i.e. all dads could camp with their sons and daughters or all moms camp with with their sons and daughters, that if no ladies can attend a camp out, as long as the female Scout's dad is in attendance, it will be allowed.

 

All because BSA is using "Family Scouting."

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

I think people are reading way too much in to the word Family than is meant.

 

 

This is the article and I agree that too many took it way out of context. No where in the article did it even mention the word scouts. This was all about getting the entire family outdoors (instead of just the scout):

 

A first-timer’s guide to camping with the whole family

https://scoutingmagazine.org/2017/08/first-timers-guide-camping-whole-family/

Link to post
Share on other sites

Perhaps the issue is a lot of us are very sensitive to what National is saying and National is not very precise in it their terms. 

 

But, regardless of what National is TRYING to say, in our Troop I have observed two conclusions (and frankly I do not want to talk about it there because I get my fill here):

 

1- The adults for the most part think Boy Scout Troops will have boys and girls in it either has boy and girl patrols or mixed gender patrols. They think this is two years away. This has been reinforced by Media coverage and GSUSA comments.

 

2- The boys, who are mixed on the girl issue, are thinking that we will be required to have "Family type" campouts (whatever that means) and Boy Scouts will be like Cub Scout campouts. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Like TT, I don't want to waste words with scouters or scouts in my district. If a handful of girls come knocking, our COR made it clear that the CO wants to try to support them, and that stupid third point of the Law will constrain me. Until then there is nothing to talk about. Some scouters have brought this up with the boys' sisters, and none of them are interested.

 

BSA really derailed themselves with all of the "family" doublespeak. When they simply market this as for girls (i.e., 4G), we can all be honest about what we're supporting or opposing. I am certain that scouters opposed to BSA4G are pro-family types just as much as those in favor of it. I loved it when Son #2's best frien took his family camping after his first summer camp. As I've said elsewhere, I'd be fine with increasing the nights required for Camping MB if nights under the stars with folks outside the boys troop (e.g., family, youth group, soccer team) could count. So, if you said "family camping" four years ago, I'd say "Great, that's one desired outcome." But by trying to use a buzzword that everyone is supposed to like for policies that people will have apprehensions about, National muddied waters needlessly and insulted the intelligence of a couple million scouts and scouters.

 

So, we've got people arguing over the lipstick on the pig when the only thing that matters is how long the bacon's cured.

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

2- The boys, who are mixed on the girl issue, are thinking that we will be required to have "Family type" campouts (whatever that means) and Boy Scouts will be like Cub Scout campouts. 

 

Cub scout campouts...tents the size of houses, enough gear to lay siege to a castle, cars literally parked everywhere, people arriving constantly, people departing constantly...do not miss those

 

Agree that the constant mention of "family" is concerning.  What does it really mean, what next will change.

  • Upvote 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Additionally, some of the same folks thinks that since Cub Scout family camping has no requirements on the genders of the adults attending, i.e. all dads could camp with their sons and daughters or all moms camp with with their sons and daughters, that if no ladies can attend a camp out, as long as the female Scout's dad is in attendance, it will be allowed.

 

All because BSA is using "Family Scouting."

 

Unless I am misunderstanding your scenario, I thought that WAS allowed.  For Cub Scouts.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My real world experience in Cub Scouts is Grandparents, Uncles, Aunts, "Friends with Benefits" (even had a former scouter neighbor) show up on family campouts not always the classic nuclear family implied in a term like 'Family Camping'. It gets messy.

 

Messy and a Youth Protection problem as well.  The YP guidelines say the youth may share a tent with a "family member" but nobody else.  Grandparents, uncles and aunts are ok; in my son's pack there was always a kid or two whose uncle was there instead of a parent.  The rest of your list are not permitted though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messy and a Youth Protection problem as well.  The YP guidelines say the youth may share a tent with a "family member" but nobody else.  Grandparents, uncles and aunts are ok; in my son's pack there was always a kid or two whose uncle was there instead of a parent.  The rest of your list are not permitted though.

No kidding but it always gets volunteered AFTER they are already there and the tent is up. I do not miss the "tent ghettos" of our Pack of 150 family campouts. There were always a few couples who 'performed for the crowd' behind thin tent walls. Awkward.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messy and a Youth Protection problem as well.  The YP guidelines say the youth may share a tent with a "family member" but nobody else.  Grandparents, uncles and aunts are ok; in my son's pack there was always a kid or two whose uncle was there instead of a parent.  The rest of your list are not permitted though.

Only the parents and court designated legal guardians or anyone with blood relations out to the 4th and 5th generation? or how about step-parents? and the list goes on and on.  Going to make YPT a nightmare.

Edited by Stosh
Link to post
Share on other sites

No kidding but it always gets volunteered AFTER they are already there and the tent is up. I do not miss the "tent ghettos" of our Pack of 150 family campouts. There were always a few couples who 'performed for the crowd' behind thin tent walls. Awkward.

 

If only there was a Guide to Safe Family Scouting.... :unsure:

Link to post
Share on other sites

What's the insurance ramifications for "family".  Would a non-custodial "step-dad" be covered?  How will he fit into YPT?  He is not a parent nor legal guardian and not registered as a scouter.  Could get interesting.

Edited by Stosh
Link to post
Share on other sites

Unless I am misunderstanding your scenario, I thought that WAS allowed.  For Cub Scouts.

 

Yes it is allowed for Cub Scouts. But I'm talking at the 11-17 yo Scout level.  Already have folks mention how if they cannot get females to camp with the girls, or camp in general since some troops have stated they will go coed anyway, that as long as dad  is camping, daughter can camp too. Which as some know from Venturing / Exploring experience, that is not the case.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes it is allowed for Cub Scouts. But I'm talking at the 11-17 yo Scout level.  Already have folks mention how if they cannot get females to camp with the girls, or camp in general since some troops have stated they will go coed anyway, that as long as dad  is camping, daughter can camp too. Which as some know from Venturing / Exploring experience, that is not the case.

 

Well now I'm confused.  I thought we were discussing tenting policy in relation to Cub Scout family camping (in which every tent has a Cub Scout and his parent(s).)  Now you are talking about the leaders-of-both-genders-on-coed-outings rule, which is a separate issue from sleeping accommodations.  ?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...