Jump to content
qwazse

YPT ... you can't have just one

Recommended Posts

lifes gonna hit these kids hard if they think taking 10 minutes to fill out an app and 30 minutes to take an online course is too much of a hassle and is taking the fun out of everything.   Or are we saying theres more to their complaint than that?

 

They already filled out the app for ASM, they already took one YPT. Plus, for Sunday school or whatever youth program they may volunteer at, they are filling out 3 sets of paperwork and taking another state-mandated program. Plus, they've registered to vote, filled out selective service applications, applied for college, secured loans and scholarships, etc ...

 

They can plan an event in 30 minutes. So, what you effectively are asking them to do is to plan one less event for their crew in what time they have allocated for scouting.

 

At some point it stops sounding like they are seeking truth, fairness, and adventure in the world and just shielding big wigs from litigation.

Edited by qwazse

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yesterday a newly-young-adult venturer said "BSA has taken the fun out of being a young adult scouter."   I'd like to hear from others "in the trenches" with dual registered young adults. Maybe I'm just in a bubble of negativity.

 

FWIW this young man is "the go to guy" for instrumental back-up at his school musical. His older brothers are always welcome to drop by and pitch in there, nobody there asks them to fill out paperwork to serve along side these impressionable youth.

 

They simply don't have the patience for this sort of thing.

 

YPT is less than 30 mins. The application is five minutes to fill out and then give it to the membership person to bring to council. Med form, if not done, is 5 minutes to fill out.

 

If these kids have even filled out ONE college application they've spent 10 times the amount of time doing that than they will spend on getting "street legal" to be an adult on a BSA event.

 

They're going to get seriously disappointed when they hit those instant gratification relievers that are DMV and IRS.

Edited by Krampus

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Patience used to be a virtue, now like common sense it's merely a historical phenomenon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
...

 

They're going to get seriously disappointed when they hit those instant gratification relievers that are DMV and IRS.

So @@Krampus, how about gathering all of your trained 18 y.o. ASMs and asking them how many would feel like taking the Venturing YPT. ... Right now, or you'll drop them from the charter?

 

The DMV get's you decent drivers and vehicles, the IRS gets you armed forces, pictures of other planets, and payments on yesteryear's social programs.

What does Venturing YPT get you that Boy Scout YPT does not? Especially for a youth who's already been venturing for 4 years?

 

Patience used to be a virtue, now like common sense it's merely a historical phenomenon.

I agree, but ...

This has nothing to do with patience. This has to do with valuing the time people have to spend on your specialty program.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So @@Krampus, how about gathering all of your trained 18 y.o. ASMs and asking them how many would feel like taking the Venturing YPT. ... Right now, or you'll drop them from the charter?

 

The DMV get's you decent drivers and vehicles, the IRS gets you armed forces, pictures of other planets, and payments on yesteryear's social programs.

What does Venturing YPT get you that Boy Scout YPT does not? Especially for a youth who's already been venturing for 4 years?

 

It gets you an adult who realizes that, once you turn 18, the world is not going to wipe your chin and give you a goodnight kiss every night.

 

It teaches them that everything worthwhile (DMV) or required (IRS) has a process. You must follow that process and endure a little pain in order to reap the benefits your time investment.

 

It teaches them that, as an adult, saying "Dude, your girlfriend is hot." to his nearly 18 Venturing friend is considered by adult YPT standards to be wrong...very wrong. Taking adult YPT welcomes him to being an adult and taking the adult courses...as silly as they are.

 

Now, if they wanted to argue the logic and reasoning behind taking IOLS when they are an Eagle Scout, staffed Rayado and summer camp, taught first year Scouts for seven years and have the outdoor skills of Les Stroud, well then, I am all ears. I agree that would be a total waste of time.

 

But 30 mins to click through some ridiculous scenarios and get a certificate? C'mon, they spend more time posting to Instagram than it would take to do YPT.

 

Better question...why should WE have to take a course that never changes having taken it 6-8 times over the last 12-16 years?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Better question...why should WE have to take a course that never changes having taken it 6-8 times over the last 12-16 years?

 

Well there was at least one MAJOR change to YP in the last 12-16 years. Initially, we were told to first report abuse incidents to the Scout Executive even though there were examples of how that had failed. It took a few years (lawsuits) to change, but finally call police first!

 

IMHO, YP training for youth educators/coaches/volunteers will likely become state regulated and replace CO, Little League, BSA ... YP's.  Like a driver's license we will need to take a training course (just once!), pass a test, issued a photo ID , and pay a registration fee. Maybe it will be an endorsement on a driver license.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

... It teaches them that, as an adult, saying "Dude, your girlfriend is hot." to his nearly 18 Venturing friend is considered by adult YPT standards to be wrong...very wrong. Taking adult YPT welcomes him to being an adult and taking the adult courses...as silly as they are. ....

Oh, how cute. You actually think that is the takeaway from the Venturing YPT course.

Suppose it's there, albeit implicitly, then, why isn't it in the Boy Scout YPT?

 

If BSA really cares, why aren't mandatory certifications for Venturing's videos about date rape and sexual harassment required before accepting a youth application?

 

 

...  But 30 mins to click through some ridiculous scenarios and get a certificate? C'mon, they spend more time posting to Instagram than it would take to do YPT.

 

Better question...why should WE have to take a course that never changes having taken it 6-8 times over the last 12-16 years?

 

You might be on to something. Maybe the YPT course should include a photo capture feature so the student can embed an instagram-ish picture of them taking the course on the certificate! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh, how cute. You actually think that is the takeaway from the Venturing YPT course.

Suppose it's there, albeit implicitly, then, why isn't it in the Boy Scout YPT?

I've seen the youth YPT. It is not as strict or topical as the adult YPT. That's the point: To hammer home that a simple statement a youth might have made when he was 17, can get him in a boat load of trouble if uttered when he's 18.

 

If BSA really cares, why aren't mandatory certifications for Venturing's videos about date rape and sexual harassment required before accepting a youth application? You might be on to something. Maybe the YPT course should include a photo capture feature so the student can embed an instagram-ish picture of them taking the course on the certificate! :D

I am not going to defend BSA training. ;) I would certainly put those issues in ANY Scout-based training for teens...especially coed Crews.

 

My point is that once you are 18 the Us considers you an adult. Why have 18 year old Crew members take a course designed for younger members and not the one all OTHER adults take?

 

If he gets in trouble the court system certainly won't think he's a minor. They will treat him as an adult. So should BSA.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If he gets in trouble the court system certainly won't think he's a minor. They will treat him as an adult. So should BSA.

 

Would that the BSA treat ALL of us who are over 18 as adults!  :mad:

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Every year I do YPT after having had a background check to get into scouting,  Every other year I do YPT,  Every time I change adult positions, I get a background check and now Venturing YPT every other year. Every time I connect up with a church youth group, I get a background check, and every time I take that group on an extended trip I get another background check. 

 

One would think that after 45 years of this, they would have a better system.  But they don't  :)  No big deal. Not my money, not my problem.  Any youth organization that requires me to pay for my own background checks gets passed by and there have been plenty of them over the years.  If the state adopts it's own certification and BSA doesn't pick up the tab on it.  I'm out of the scouting business immediately.  Same for the churches and other community youth programs I work with. 

 

I'll be down to volunteering for the Salvation Army and Red Cross only, but that can keep me busy too.  Red Cross has youth programs as well.  And by the way, there was a background check to work with the Red Cross too.  :)  I'm waiting for a background check on bell ringing.  Haven't seen anything on that yet.  :)

 

This summer I'll be doing volunteer work for the community garden, I don't think there's a background check for pulling weeds... :rolleyes:

Edited by Stosh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In some states, if you go to a council camp and you are an in-state unit, you need to do face-to-face YPT. 8 hours of the same 30 minutes you get online.

 

One reason why we camp out of state for summer camp. Not going to waste 8 hours doing a useless training session.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In some states, if you go to a council camp and you are an in-state unit, you need to do face-to-face YPT. 8 hours of the same 30 minutes you get online.

 

One reason why we camp out of state for summer camp. Not going to waste 8 hours doing a useless training session.

In the three councils around here, two schedule F2F YPT for one hour and one schedules it for 1.5 hrs. Yours is eight hours?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the three councils around here, two schedule F2F YPT for one hour and one schedules it for 1.5 hrs. Yours is eight hours?

 

Yup. All day. Once a year it is offered. Maybe twice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah. The punishment will continue until morale improves.

 

Can you go to a neighboring council? I have five within fifty miles

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah. The punishment will continue until morale improves.Can you go to a neighboring council? I have five within fifty miles

Easier, and more pleasurable, to go out of state for summer camp. ;)

 

Also gets me out of staffing council stuff. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×