Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by SSScout

  1. Doesn't Scouts Canada have a highest rank, equivalent to the BSA Eagle? If she earned much of her Scout Skills in the Scouts Canada program, perhaps Ms Ireland might pursue that ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen's_Venturer_Award
  2. SSScout

    Faith and Chaplaincy Issues

    Always good to see questions concerning religious bias here in the Faith and Chaplaincy forum. Oh, wait...
  3. SSScout

    Duty to God question

    Always good to see reasoned discussion here in the Faith and Chaplaincy forum. Oh, wait....
  4. SSScout

    Eagle Workbook questions

    Yeah, pity the poor Assyrian Scout. That cuneiform is a real bear to get straight on that clay....
  5. SSScout

    Duty to God question

    While I have your attention, I am reminded of the agnostic, dyslexic insomniac. Poor man lay awake all night wondering if there is a dog....
  6. SSScout

    Duty to God question

    *sigh* "By their fruits ye shall know them". Most Scouts do their DtG without even knowing it. This is, as has been said, not a pass/fail thing. "Tie a bowline" Yep. "Point out Poison Ivy". Yep. "Recite the Scout Promise". Yep. "Live your life according to the Scout Law and Promise." ummmmmm . . . When I served as a Scout Chaplain at the Jambo, one of my duties was to sit in the "Relationship" pavilion and be "available". The Scout could earn a patch (!) by coming by and visiting their faith's exhibit. If they didn't have one, (didn't profess a faith, faith wasn't there) they could speak with the "Chaplain di jour" (me). In my 5 hour stint, I met Scouts with unique faiths (Jain? Taoist? Sikh?) and learned alittle myself. And I met a few Scouts that said, in essence, "I'm not so sure about this God stuff." and we would talk. My fellow Chaplains told similar stories. Draw them out. Logic? Science proof? Is humanity the final power in the universe? Is Catholicism/Hinduism/Buddhism/Taoism/Protestantism (choose and -ism) the final word? Define religion? I heard talk about searching, asking, wondering, finding problems without answers, that's what a Scout should be about.... Now if the Scout poo poos the idea and naysays religion and denigrates any faith, then I have a problem with his/her abidance with the twelveth point....
  7. SSScout

    Lightweight Rain Jackets

    Choices: Over the pack, large poncho is good for standing around in the rain. I hiked with one , and concluded the sweat incurred while hiking with pack condensed on the inside of the poncho. It was almost like not wearing one. Standing still, not much problem. I have a gortex clone Marmot over the hip jacket that I like. It breathes, and sheds water. I will say, as it ages, the goretex Teflon stuff gets "dirty" and eventually passes liquid water. Ventilated vinyl ? Coated nylon? Gortex breathing fabric? Helly Hansen foul weather gear? When I rode my motorcycle regularly, I came to love the heavy duty absolutely rain and wind proof Helly Hansen rain suit I bought. Buy BIG, so it has room for breezes and even a sweater if it gets cool.
  8. SSScout

    Who's got these Boy Scout Movies?

    Do cartoon tv shows count? Rowan Atkinson, animated....
  9. SSScout

    Got acronyms?

    IOLS Introduction to Outdoor Leader Skills BALOO Basic Adult Leader Outdoor Orientation WWend Webelos Week End ASM Assistant Scoutmaster UC Unfortunate Commish DC Distinctive Commish ADC Assisting Distinctive Commish DDC Deputy District Commish RTC Round Table Commish ARTC Assistant RTC PPFF Purdue Perpetual Fudge Factor
  10. SSScout

    On a less serious note....

    Scoutmaster’s Song (with apologies to Gilbert and Sullivan) When A Scouter’s not engaged in his employment (his employment) or planning to go camping with his Troop (with his Troop) his capacity for innocent enjoyment (-cent enjoyment) Can easily be knocked off for a loop (for a loop) Our feelings we with difficulty smother (-culty smother) When some Scoutmasterly duty’s to be done (to be done) Ah, take one consideration with another, (with another) A Scoutmaster’s lot is not a happy one. Ooooohhhhh… When Scoutmasterly duty’s to be done, to be done, A Scoutmaster’s lot is not a happy one. When the helicopter parent is not hov’ring (is not a hov’ring) When the Scout is not a-cutting off their thumb (-off their thumb) He loves to hear the bug-a-ler a-bugling (bugler bugling) And enjoy his tea while sitting on his bum (on his bum) When the PLC has finally decided (has decided) Where the Troop should hike on weekends yet to come (yet to come) Ah, take one consideration with another (with another) A scoutmaster’s lot is not a happy one. Ooooooohhhhh, When Scoutmasterly duty’s to be done, to be done, , His duty is often not a happy one. (happy one).
  11. SSScout

    Icarus dilemma

    Thoughts? I never got to hike in Philmont. The senior Scouts from my Troop used army surplus plywood packframes, made their own tarp tents out of 8 mil black plastic , duct tape, and grommets, came back hyped up. Our Troop went camping a lot after that. Since the older Scouts used 'em, dad and I went out and bought the M4 plywood packframe for me, lashed the BSA Yucca pack to it, and that is what I used thru the late 1950s. No hip belt, canvas, cotton cord. When the canvas backpad started to give way, I found a open mesh one that fit and that made a world of difference in comfort. Then a friend brought a Swiss rucksack. Aluminum frame, hip belt , nylon. Wow. Instant conversion. I got a Kelty/REI packframe, and then even tried to convert the M4 with a homemade heavy hinge hip belt thingy, which bent under the load. The M4 is ready for the museum.... When my friend invited me to walk the Camino de Santiago with him, I went out and bought a new Deuter pack. I think I had a max 20 kilos . Very comfortable, extra roomy, served very well. I crafted some rings on the bottom of the pack to lash the sleeping bag to, keeping the light weight stuff on the bottom. I believe I still would favor an external frame as being more adaptable, but the internal frame Deuter was very nice. Pockets on the outside for small stuff... Rain cape, Such choices available now. "Ya pays yer money and ya takes yer cherce."
  12. Here's another life lesson for the Scout. Who do you ask for a reference? When they say no, for whatever reason, what do you do then? In the Eagle candidate's case, I really don't think it's going to make much difference. Attesting to a person's character, history , accomplishments, loyalty to an ideal (God? Creator? J-w-h? ) , is difficult at best. Again, would the lack of the letters be a reason for an Eagle denial ? Some years ago, when I needed some support for a denial I had been given, I was very gratified and surprised by the folks that came to my aid. Their refutation of the rationale given for the denial (buy me a coffee and pie for the whole story) was amazing and made me glad for their friendship and my relationship with them. References are for folks that do not know the candidate to begin with. They can help the BoR to know the candidate..
  13. SSScout

    Treating injuries

    Summer Scout camp, lots of fun, lots of "growing up".... He accidentally hurt himself . His parents noticed the injury when they picked up their camper. He said he did NOT tell an adult when it happened, treated himself "correctly". Within 48 hours of his injury, his family took him to an ER and he is now on antibiotics, under a physicians care. Have I got all that right? When, exactly, as the SM did you become aware of this injury? What actions (report to camp authorities, , professional examination, treatment, etc.) did YOU, the adult authority, do ? How forgiving, understanding is the family? How old, experienced is the Scout? How afraid of punishment for doing something "stupid" is the Scout? Lots of collateral considerations here. Do you have a family lawyer? Just thinking out loud here.....
  14. Read the fine print, """ References: Must list all six (five if not employed). If not affiliated with an organized religion, then the parent or guardian provides this reference. There are no restrictions on who the Scout may list as the two other references. The candidate may list anyone, including parents or guardians not previously listed, other relatives, Scout leaders including those from the candidate’s unit, or other Scouts and friends. There is no requirement that any of the references be 21 years of age or older. "" (from https://www.scouting.org/resources/guide-to-advancement/eagle-scout-rank/ ) In my career, I have never heard of any candidate have his references questioned. Of course, a candidate wouldn't list folks he might not expect a good comment from.
  15. SSScout

    Who's got these Boy Scout Movies?

  16. SSScout

    Who's got these Boy Scout Movies?

    Is "Hatchet" optioned yet?
  17. SSScout

    Who's got these Boy Scout Movies?

    Howzabout this: ""Young Eagles (1934)"" *** When their around-the-world plane trip is halted by a crash in the Ecuadorian jungle, plucky Eagle Scouts Bobby (Bobby Cox) and Jim (Jim Vance) will need all their survival skills as they battle wild animals, hostile natives, and ruthless, treasure-seeking bandits to reach safety in this thrill-packed serial. Carter Dixon co-stars. 12 episodes; 3 3/4 hrs. on two discs. Standard; Soundtrack: English. ((TCM Store catalog))
  18. SSScout

    Patrol Method not so much

    Friend Fred: I was in the Eagle Patrol in my Scout Troop It had been the Eagle Patrol for some years previous, had gear collected, a "treasury bag", and ribbons on it's Patrol flag (!). I was in the Eagle Patrol until I graduated out of Scouts. It was in existence for some years, I found out, after I left, but eventually dissipated when the Troop came on hard times. Same Patrol, different boys coming in and out. Different ages , therefore. As I got older, I went from Patrol member, to Patrol Quartermaster (cook kits, tents/tarps) and treasurer, and Patrol Leader. Assigning chores on hikes and camp outs was the toughest part, I guess. That is my model in judging B-P's "traditional" Patrol. I had friends of my age and older and younger in it. When I visit the Troop Meeting place/CO, I look at the Eagle Plaque and remember the faces..... The other two types I generalized about usually last only as long as there are Scouts of a certain age or rank. Even the "new boy" Patrol is designed to disappear when the Scouts get too old. If a Scout only has the one type of Troop/Patrol to experience, they may say "that's the way Patrols SHOULD work" and leave it at that. If the Troop Adults don't worry about their interference ("we' have to control and make everything safe") in the Scout culture, then that will be the Troop culture. I still remember my stints as a sub teacher, and how hard it is to get today's middle schoolers to give out an original idea, rather than sit there and wait for the teacher's instruction.....
  19. SSScout

    Patrol Method not so much

    Rain: Your comment about the Scouts forming informal groups is telling. A Patrol should be a bunch of friends to learn/go/do/see/hangout/camp/hike/movie/ together. As you go thru Scouting, you will see three types of Patrols, which leads to three types of Troops: **The traditional Patrol is mixed age, the older Scouts just naturally gravitate to leadership positions. New Scouts are assigned to a Patrol because their buddies are there, the Patrol has room (no more than eight), or the Scouts have gravitated there due to neighborhood. The Troop may/may not have a ASM "Troop Guide" assigned to "advise". Usually, this type of Patrol leads to a Senior Scout cadre, who go off to do High Adventure Stuff, too, separate from the original Patrols. Troop may name Instructors, but the PL is expected to train "his" Scouts in the various skills, and often pass them for rank. Traditionally, the Patrol MIGHT (!) have "Patrol Dad" as a mentor, but not always. Patrol only activities are expected, encouraged. Adult accompaniment may /may not be seen as required. ** The Age Patrol has all the Scouts of the same age and general rank. They joined together (crossed over Webelos?) and stay together. This leads the Troop to have older Patrols and younger Patrols, which often makes it hard for any type of competitions. The older Patrols rank out, become Venturers, and leave the younger ones behind. eleven year old PL? yep. By it's very nature, the Troop assigns a ASM Patrol Guide to the Patrol, to "guide " them. Yes, there can be Patrol Only activities, but the ASM guide must approve.... ** New Scout Patrol (method) has the new Scouts all in one Patrol for the first year at least, during which time they are encouraged/required/led/expected to gain First Class. After the first year, the Scout is re-assigned to another Patrol, which may/may not be one of the first two types, "depending". The Troop that has this construct is seen as the "Adult Led" Troop. Nothing is done without the permission and planning of the Adult ASMs. There are no Patrol Activities, only under the aegis of the Troop (adult) leadership. The examples above are observed definitions. Here's an example: If a Troop 666 has a campout planned/held and the Patrols are small, oh, let's say the Stinging Nettle Patrol has 8 Scouts on the roster , but only three will be coming, and the Muddy Gumper Patrol has 7 on it's roster but only one will be coming and the Rolling Laughter Patrol has 4 on it's roster and all 4 are coming, the first Troop above would have each Patrol camp/cook/work as they come. One Scout is a Patrol here... Type two and three however, would say , meld the attending Scouts into ONE Troop Patrol for this campout. That's efficient and what the heck, the Scouts are camping, right? What is the difference between the two types of camp?
  20. I guess times have changed. I grew up in a family that went out of their way (looking back on it) to help in the community. My dad was a Lion, club president for some years. My mom was deep in the PTA, other local clubs, wrote a column in the local paper, They just did stuff, and I tagged along, helped out where I could , I remember many of my friends were of the same sort, not just in Scouts. Finding satisfaction in DOING and finishing a job. We mowed the church lawn (now it's a pro outfit), served at the church /VFD dinners, variety show raised money for various charities, the Lion's Club Horse show (I ran messages, watched the gate, led horses, ) school service club (Key Club? Leos?) were active. I remember it was fun, doing "adult stuff" , with my parents' friends. Have the kids lost the example from "millennial" parents who forgot what their parents did? When I was elected/tapped for OA, it seemed to be another step in that growth. The ordeal was a camping test (it RAINED !), and the service just a continuation of what seemed to be an expectation. Help at the Camporee? The Salamagundi? At the Scoutaree? That's what we did for the other Scouts coming up. The OA were senior, older Scouts. We taught. We led, but not so much with a finger point as with a glance over our shoulder, if you catch my meaning. I still see some of that , but maybe this thread/discussion has made me think that such civic mindedness is not as prevalent as it once was? The volunteer fire company cannot be staffed so easily any more by local businessmen and farmers who would drop their tools at the sound of the siren and come running to the firehouse. Now, the county has a professional core of wonderful "first responders" that smile and nod at the volunteers that still work to equip the fire companies and keep up the training standards, all because they think they "should". Perhaps the perceived OA "crisis" is another symptom of the friction between the Scout Led/Patrol Method and the adults who sign the check book that are afraid the kids won't do it right the first time.....
  21. SSScout

    Activity approval

    Yep. When I promote Scouting, I speak of "Safe Adventure". We teach knots and ropes so the tents don't fall down and the backpack stays on the back and the canoe stays on the cartop. We teach camp cooking and fire safety so the kids won't be poisoned by their own cuisine and the woods will still be there next month. We teach map and compass so the Mountain Rescue Corps can sleep in over the weekend. We want the Scouts to make Good Decisions, rather than have the SM hear "HEY ! WATCH THIS !" The good decisions made are self rewarding. The poor decisions may not have a second chance. Scouting, by it's design, allows for SOME poor decisions. That's where the SM comes in....
  22. SSScout

    Can a CO profit off a unit?

    Fascinating, Captain.... Start out discussing Fundraising/working on behalf of the unit's CO and end up debating the merits of particular spiritual leanings.... Here are the choices I discuss in my IOLS section on "Scout's Own": 1) Nada. Religion is up to the family, not the Scout unit. Pack up and go home... 2) If your group is of a particular faith, plan and execute your faith service accordingly. 3) if it is "mostly" Christian, or "mostly" something, (Interfaith, Non-denominational, ) still tread politely and carefully. 4) What I call "spiritually mushy but suggestive". Here we are in God's own cathedral /house of worship/etc. out in the woods.... When I became a Jamboree Scout Chaplain, I used Father Mulcahy as my tutor. I learned a lot about other faiths. The Golden Rule is common, in one form or another , in every faith I have dealt with. I was once asked to organize a Interfaith Service for a camporee. I said, "do you mean a Scout's Own Service?" and the PTB said "yeah, I guess that's what I mean". I asked that they announce that all Unit Chaplain Aides meet with me at a certain time for 15 minutes. Out of 35 Troops, I had eight CAs come. I handed them my "sample" Scout's Own from the IOLS course, said you boys are better at this than I am, we need a 15 or 20 minute spiritual, inspirational worship service. If you need me, I'll be around. Those CAs had , I think, never worked together before. They hand copied some stuff, developed two "sermons" about Scouting and Earth Stewardship. The Sunday morning service was sensitive, thought provoking, respectful and got thanks from many folks.
  23. Dinosaur fossil hunt? Nothing could be more Scouty…. ""....Arlton Murray, who worked with fossils at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History, hid his own time capsule in a dinosaur installation in 1947. The wooden box — containing Murray’s Boy Scout membership card and a note about one of the installations — was a surprise find five years ago as the museum’s Fossil Hall was taken apart for renovation...."" ""...It took a bit of research to discover the significance of the Boy Scout card . . . Murray discovered his passion for fossils on a Boy Scout outing. "" https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/kidspost/?utm_term=.20cf958898ee He was a Scoutmaster in 1945.....
  24. Our Meeting made almost ten dollars the first day this was installed.... Easy to build, DIY , perhaps an Eagle Service Project for your church?
  25. SSScout

    My Way Or The Highway

    Yep... A Scout is Brave.... It all depends on how untenable the situation is, and whether one either transfers out or tries to improve things where one is.