Leaderboard

I think @InquisitiveScouter is jokingly saying that it’s up to the SPL (with the guidance of the SM) to determine the “when” and “how.” One size need not fit all.

I don’t think you do. Your response is very bizzar-o. This is a fun tool they the SPL can use. People have been kind and quoted original resources. An SM can share that with the SPL. The SPL can then choose what, if any, methods to use. If the SM thinks the SPL got it wrong, then they can talk. Patrol yells are super informal and very very minor. I don’t understand why you are putting them on such a high pedestal. I’m not getting what you are getting at.

The following medical contraindications are based on BSA operational considerations and may be more conservative than those listed in the “Diving Medical Guidance to the Physician.” Emphasis added above.

to part of that question my state does not treat them as motorized vehicles until they are greater than 750 watt. So are much greater

Nepal Scouts got right back to me! Off to a good start. May this benefit all sentient beings

YES! To all the above, and more! How can the answer to “when and how does the SPL call for patrol yells?” be “YES!”?

Okay, these are good ideas, but when the patrols give their yells when forming up, just when and how do they do it? What does the SPL say to trigger these yells? Are they all done at the same time?

I see. So none of the experienced adults here have any idea how this can be done successfully, but we expect a 14-year-old to figure out how to do it on his own. Shall we have Scouts figure out how to tie knots without instruction as well?