Over generations, some basic concepts were accepted:
Program quality - outdoors, excitement, challenge, Scout planned and led - drives membership.
Advancement is a result of quality program and, otherwise, a bad idea.
Advancement is not a goal of Scouting.
Program is to be experiential - Scouts learn and grow by doing.
Scouting is not to be anything like school.
I see little sign that National is committed to any of these points.