Jump to content

Open Discussion - Program

Share Scouting Topics here.

Subforums

  1. Scouts with Disabilities

    Where parents and scouters go to discuss unique aspects to working with kids with special challenges.

    712
    posts
  2. Going to the next Jamboree?

    A place to chat about Scouting's biggest gathering

    2758
    posts

8909 topics in this forum

    • 112 replies
    • 6079 views
    • 32 replies
    • 10048 views
    • 10 replies
    • 793 views
    • 5 replies
    • 172 views
    • 337 replies
    • 8209 views
    • 247 replies
    • 14175 views
    • 243 replies
    • 11481 views
    • 232 replies
    • 11184 views
    • 218 replies
    • 9292 views
    • 204 replies
    • 7788 views
    • 200 replies
    • 10711 views
  1. God?

    • 189 replies
    • 5922 views
    • 178 replies
    • 10380 views
  2. Earrings

    • 168 replies
    • 5554 views
    • 157 replies
    • 4464 views
  • LATEST POSTS

    • To be fair, @Jackdaws asked the question in the OP in a way that supports a particular message:
    • Et. al, You've heard me state my Rule #1: Don't ask for a rule. You'll get one. That holds here! What I feel is useful is understanding. The incident reviews constitute a great step in this direction. What are some of the issues with Cubs and more than one consecutive overnight campout? Resident camps may have something to offer in terms of risks observed after night 2 vs. night 1. Maybe the Risk Management talked to some psychologists and there's something different when a pack spends time in the woods vs. a couple of extended families. Maybe, historically,  BSA has wanted councils to own consecutive overnights for cubs. Disambiguation only let's people know if they are compliant, background gives them the ability to improve their judgement.
    • So I did browse through the survey, as my son received the invitation.  A lot of it is rating experience with call out, feelings about call out, feelings about Ordeal experience, etc.  There was one question along the lines of "do you feel the BSA is headed in the right direction", with the response choices of agree or disagree, but there were sadly no follow ups on that thread.  Seemed very oddly out of place to me that it didn't have any true direct follow up questions getting to why scouts felt one way or the other.  There were some indirectly related questions later in the survey, on the level of participation for the respondent (such as I attend meetings frequently, infrequently, etc.).  
    • Several of the BSA surveys I've responded to over the years have used design mechanisms that can skew answers. Many surveys do this and it's why you have to be skeptical of survey results. When BSA issues a survey, they are generally looking for data that will support some marketing message they will eventually spin out. 
       
    • @Jackdaws, I believe they read the surveys.  But that's all they do. Councils and National work to their own complete satisfaction.  Anything other than praise is ignored.
  • Who's Online (See full list)

×