2nd class map/compass hiking requirement
Dean Hayes (dhayes@BVU-LADS.LORAL.COM)
Thu, 9 May 1996 08:59:00 -0700
Bob Myers, SM Troop 575, Cincinnati, Ohio writes:
> IMO, this is the only requirement that is technically impossible for a
> Scout to do. In order to use a compass as required on the hike, the map
> must be drawn accurately to scale. The BSA Scout Handbook describes how
> to do this on pages 198-199. However, the Handbook shows how to map a
> campsite or other small area, not an area large enough to take a 5 mile
> hike in. It would take a group of professionals many days to produce
> such a map without the use of aerial photography, lasers, etc.
The exact wording of the 2nd class requirement states:
1b. Using a compass and a map you've drawn, take a 5-mile hike (or
10 miles by bike) approved by your adult leader and your parent or
guardian. (If you are using a wheelchair or crutches, or if it is
difficult for you to get around, you may substitute "trip" for
"hike" in this requirement.)
I have had a problem with this requirement because of its wording (what
exactly is the scout supposed to do with the map and compass during the
hike).
During a SM conference with one of my scouts, I asked what he had done
and what he thought of the requirement:
His father (with prior approval) had the scout draw a map of where he
wanted to go and they took the map and compass with them. Any time
there was a change in direction, they stopped, the scout took a
compass bearing, and recorded the bearing on the map.
The response to my question of what he thought of the requirement
was, Boy I sure now know how to take a compass bearing!
At this point I pretty much understood the intent of the requirement.
Under the no more/no less philosphy I have come to the conclusion that
it is not necessary to have the map drawn accurately to scale, have N/S
lines etc. It must be sufficient for the scout to follow the route.
The real learning is the constant use of the compass to know the
direction your going.
I still don't see how to work this requirement as a group outing (troop
hike) if everyone is supposed to be following their own map.
--
Dean Hayes
SM, Troop 491, Snoqualmie, WA
Lockheed Martin
Advanced Distributed Simulation
(206) 957-3212
Terry Howerton Sakima Group, Inc. SCOUTER Magazine Kansas City | 
